Grade My Jimmy

[nik]

Only negative besides the spine ticks that I see is, on the back cover edge, a tiny 1/8 tear.

[awe4one]

9.0

[divad]

9.2 (for the tear we can't see...)

 

Those spine ticks are not a problem.

[FFB]

8.5 to 9.0.

[blutobc]

maybe its the big scan, but I was thinking 8.5 at best

[blutobc]

But on a more positive note.....

 

Kirby 4th World Jimmy Olsens are "sweet", they may not make a lot of sense at times...but that is part of the attraction for me.

[Old_Skool]

Nice little book.I would put her at 9.0 but not sure how the tear would affect that grade.

[143ksk]

VF/NM 9.0

[garthgantu]

8.5 at best.

 

Over a dozen spine stresses breaking color to varying degrees

Small corner crease URC

Blunted corner LRC

Some 'raggedness' along lower edge

Back cover 1/8" tear

 

Great cover, and still a nice book...

[nik]

8.5 at best.

 

Over a dozen spine stresses breaking color to varying degrees

Small corner crease URC

Blunted corner LRC

Some 'raggedness' along lower edge

Back cover 1/8" tear

 

Great cover, and still a nice book...

 

All that plus the fact that I generally do not do as well with DC as opposed to Marvel submissions, I am starting to feel like this book may grade as a VF

[divad]

8.5 at best.

 

Over a dozen spine stresses breaking color to varying degrees

Small corner crease URC

Blunted corner LRC

Some 'raggedness' along lower edge

Back cover 1/8" tear

 

Great cover, and still a nice book...

 

All that plus the fact that I generally do not do as well with DC as opposed to Marvel submissions, I am starting to feel like this book may grade as a VF

 

Garth is nuts, just send the book to me instead!

[nik]

On Ebay

[supapimp]

8.0