PGM: X-Men king size special #1

[simply2fly]

The book is horribly miscut - how much does that impact the grade?

 

 

[GLCBrad]

If you post a scan that doesn't cut off half of the book- then I'll tell you

[simply2fly]

The book is miscut, that is an accurate representation of the front and back.

 

Not sure what you mean by 1/2 the book...

[GLCBrad]

Your scan cuts off the entire right side and bottom edges of the book. We can't grade something that isn't doesn't have visible crucial components

 

I apologize if my comment came off as negative- that wasn't intended

 

Just re-scan it with all edges visible

 

WTTB!

[simply2fly]

Ok, the scan did cut off a bit. Let me redo it... but the printing isn't square on it... there is actually a border of white at the bottom which messed up the detecting function.

[rjpb]

The book is miscut, that is an accurate representation of the front and back.

 

Not sure what you mean by 1/2 the book...

 

He means your scans are cropped, making it difficult to assess condition.

[GLCBrad]

Also- miscuts have minimal to no impact in CGC's eyes.

[simply2fly]

Ok, definitely see what you meant... I didn't realize that much had been cut off. THANKS!

[GLCBrad]

Much much much much much better

[GLCBrad]

I don't see the miswrap hurt this grade. The bottom corner on the other hand...

 

I'm somewhere in the 8.0ish range

[Phicks]

8.0, IMHO.

[timfinz]

7.5 IMHO! Corner chip on the TRHC front cover, the impact damage and tear on the LRHC and the crease on the LLHC of the back cover.

[divad]

The miscut won't impact the grade at all, just the desirability and ease of sale. Solid 8.0 btw.

 

The book is horribly miscut - how much does that impact the grade?

 

 

[divad]

7.5 IMHO! Corner chip on the TRHC front cover, the impact damage and tear on the LRHC and the crease on the LLHC of the back cover.

 

Ever consider actually looking at a grading guide?

[timfinz]

7.5 IMHO! Corner chip on the TRHC front cover, the impact damage and tear on the LRHC and the crease on the LLHC of the back cover.

 

Ever consider actually looking at a grading guide?

 

Wow! There's a in every crowd!