Would you rather have a 5.0 CGC graded or 6.0 graded by good dealer

[1Cool]

For example would you rather have a 5.0 graded Stg. Fury #5 or a tightly graded 6.0 from a dealer. If you could see nice big scans of front and back would you pick the graded or ungraded? Prices for both books are the same.

[GIJOEISAWESOME-migration]

**Quickly checks all internet website to find book in quest and purchase**

[Green]

6.0 from a dealer trust.

[Bill1]

CGC everytime, but you didn't say if there was a price difference....

[porky]

Is the price the same on both? If so, I'd take the one that looked best to me.

[bababooey]

For example would you rather have a 5.0 graded Stg. Fury #5 or a tightly graded 6.0 from a dealer. If you could see nice big scans of front and back would you pick the graded or ungraded?

I'd go with the 6.0 if it was in person...if it was two e-bay purchases I'd probably go with the 5.0 CGC

 

[Dr. Balls]

For example would you rather have a 5.0 graded Stg. Fury #5 or a tightly graded 6.0 from a dealer. If you could see nice big scans of front and back would you pick the graded or ungraded?

I'd go with the 6.0 if it was in person...if it was two e-bay purchases I'd probably go with the 5.0 CGC

 

+1

[bffnut]

If they were the same price and the 6.0 looked nicer, I would buy the latter and send it off to be graded.

[bffnut]

For example would you rather have a 5.0 graded Stg. Fury #5 or a tightly graded 6.0 from a dealer. If you could see nice big scans of front and back would you pick the graded or ungraded?

I'd go with the 6.0 if it was in person...if it was two e-bay purchases I'd probably go with the 5.0 CGC

 

+1

 

+ ∞

[stanley1883]

Asuuming price is the same, I'd buy the one the looks nicer. Maybe the dealer graded one will come back as a 6....

[Jeffro.]

Raw every time from a trusted seller

[jsilverjanet]

go raw, just make sure you use (paypal) protection

 

 

[HarveySwick]

Raw from a trusted dealer. (thumbs u

[Ebel 1911]

CGC for me

 

[Ebel 1911]

**Quickly checks all internet website to find book in quest and purchase**

 

[DeadpoolJr.]

In person the raw if from a reputable dealer with a proven track record, and online the CGC graded one. Is the price the same though also, cause that can effect a person's decision?

[Dark Knight]

Buy the book, not the label

[Bomber-Bob]

I'd go for the book with the better Page Quality !!!!

[DeadpoolJr.]

I'd go for the book with the better Page Quality !!!!

The both have the same.

[DrWatson]

Dealer graded 6.0.