PGM ASM 300 (yeah another one)

[Barth]

THANK YOU! (thumbs u

 

 

[W16227]

I'm nowhere near where I need to be on grading - but I can point out what I see......

 

 

front cover

 

upper left corner - small tear

lower left corner - abraded corner

 

right edge looks rough

 

two small spine stress marks

 

rear cover

 

one spine stress mark

lower right bottom - scuffing

 

 

I would say 8.5 without the right cover edge "roughness" - no idea where that puts things.

 

 

and I am NOT a good reference - just want to see how my guess stands up against the experts

 

 

 

[timfinz]

9.4 IMHO!

The "rough cut" edge on the RHS is a known flaw with this book that does not have an effect on the grade. This book also, in my opinion and from what I have seen lately coming back from CGC is graded rather "loosely", which is why when viewing this copy the main flaw seems to be a loose corner and a few minor spine stresses on an otherwise beautiful copy!

[SuperiorSpiderMan]

9.2

 

 

[SteveC77]

Agreed 9.2. Shame about that bottom left.

[Conan_Aficionado]

9.4 unless CGC has changed their stance on binary hears.

 

otherwise owl, it's a SEVEN POINT O.

[eeb03]

9.2

[Barth]

Thanks everyone. I have another rough cut one that I'll list here soon.

[divad]

Agreed 9.2. Shame about that bottom left.

 

As CTA states, that bindery chip should not affect the grade, and as T points out the rough RE is a production defect. It's a slam-dunk 9.4, with a chance at a 9.6.

 

Nice copy! (thumbs u

[KEY ISSUES Comics]

I say 9.6!!!