Figured!

[SteveoSupremeo]

Would 1.5 be pushing it for these books?

 

#1 The spine seems to have been completely tapped. Yet, it doesn't seem to have more than 1" spine spilt. Contains some mold on the back that can and maybe cut out

 

#4 Just has the luck of having a ratted spine. No complete splits at the bottom or top. Missing 3 MM of the spine.

 

 

Thanks guys!

[SteveoSupremeo]

image upload software

 

how to capture screen

[SteveoSupremeo]

how to make screen shot

 

screenshot capture

[timfinz]

I think 1.5 is a fair assessment for both issues!

[SteveoSupremeo]

It's an easy grade. To the for sale page! !!

[SteveC77]

I think #1 is 1.0-1.5... #4 closer to 1.0. Both are awesome books. At the moment X-Men #4 is one of the hottest comics on the planet.

[rjpb]

If not for the tape I'd put the #1 at 1.5, as is I'd call it a FR+. Since CGC doesn't recognize that grade, and as a result there is no generally accepted number for it, 1.0 or 1.5 both work for me.

 

The #4 is what I call beat but complete, as it has no chunks out, and is actually holding together, it's another one you could call a 1.5 as readily as a 1.0.

 

Short answer: You're not pushing the grades beyond acceptability, and they speak for themselves anyway.