PGM: Black Panther #1

[tchalla8]

Afternoon, gentlemen!. Been a while since I've been out here. Thoughts on this one? I can't find much to criticize here.

 

 

[Supa-Bad-Mofo]

I'd say a strong 9.4. Having issues with that very small color breaking bend LRC and the bindery tear/rounded TLC on the front cover that might keep it out of the 9.6 category. Never know though...I have 9.6's that have worse!

[Scturo]

Clean copy, Slight LRC damage, if I'm seeing it right, 8.5/9.0

[topcat54]

I'd say a strong 9.4. Having issues with that very small color breaking bend LRC and the bindery tear/rounded TLC on the front cover that might keep it out of the 9.6 category. Never know though...I have 9.6's that have worse!

 

Plus it is not very well centered.I would go with a 9.4 maybe 9.6

[tchalla8]

Any more thoughts? I'm giving serious consideration to sending this one in.

[Gem_Mint]

I'd say a strong 9.4. Having issues with that very small color breaking bend LRC and the bindery tear/rounded TLC on the front cover that might keep it out of the 9.6 category. Never know though...I have 9.6's that have worse!

 

Plus it is not very well centered.I would go with a 9.4 maybe 9.6

 

I thought centering didn't affect grade?

[SuperiorSpiderMan]

9.2 / 9.4

 

 

[DavidTheDavid]

Any more thoughts? I'm giving serious consideration to sending this one in.

If it were mind, I'd submit it. I think it's an easy 9.4, decent shot at 9.6.

[joeypost]

Corner might be bindery related. Centering has no affect on the grade the way it is. 9.4/9.6 unless it has a surface defect the scanner does not pick up.

[cpannell]

Very white whites! Especially on that much-discussed 'centering.'

 

Could well be a 9.6.

[timfinz]

9.4 IMHO! Nice copy!