PGM TOS 59

[aggr1103]

I'm trying to get better at grading. I know the ballpark for this book but I'd like to get closer to an acceptable number grade and wanted some opionions:

 

 

The piece off to the right of the book is from the 1st page. There's a 1" tear along the edge. The piece is still there, its just hanging out beyond the right edge of the book.

[Conan_Aficionado]

that 1" tear on the cover or interior page?

 

2.0/2.5

[aggr1103]

that 1" tear on the cover or interior page?

 

2.0/2.5

 

Interior page.

[timfinz]

2.5 IMHO!

[ROBTOTHEC]

I will go a touch higher and say a possible 3.0.

But I can certainly see it at 2.5.

[cpannell]

Ouch. That water damage in the bottom right corner is a killer. And there's a lot of damage at the top of the spine.

 

3.0

[aggr1103]

Ouch. That water damage in the bottom right corner is a killer. And there's a lot of damage at the top of the spine.

 

3.0

 

Yeah. I thought it presented really nice except for that bottom corner. Still looks good in a mylar though.

[conditionfreak]

2.5 all day long. If you submit during the summer, and right day of the week, possibly a 3.0

[Scturo]

2.5, was just looking at my copy, great comic

[SuperiorSpiderMan]

2.5 IMHO!

 

+1

 

 

[FineCollector]

that 1" tear on the cover or interior page?

 

2.0/2.5

 

Yup. I should grade all my books this way:

 

"I think it's... / CGC says it's..."