PGM Marvel Preview 7

[mcnick]

I am looking to sell the comic on here eventually, but want to know what grade everyone thinks it is beforehand. Thanks!

 

[tjanse]

Kinda bad scan so I got no idea what going on what the top part of the book.

 

1.8

Paper loss lower right corner

Multiple creases that break color

Two long vertical crease

Top staple paper tear

Water damage

Water stain on back

Doesn't lie flat (book waves)

Honestly looks like book got wet someone tried to dry it it

 

Still neat book

I'm guessing you had it in the 3.0 area?

[Vision75]

Kinda bad scan so I got no idea what going on what the top part of the book.

 

1.8

Paper loss lower right corner

Multiple creases that break color

Two long vertical crease

Top staple paper tear

Water damage

Water stain on back

Doesn't lie flat (book waves)

Honestly looks like book got wet someone tried to dry it it

 

Still neat book

I'm guessing you had it in the 3.0 area?

 

I might be a little more generous than a 1.8, but it is hard to tell with the given scan. Tjanse does have a keen eye though.

[mcnick]

Better pictures were added

[tjanse]

How many pages of paper loss? Pics are a little better but still missing the bottom right corner in new ones!

[mcnick]

Around 35 of 65 have a small amount of paper loss.

[mcnick]

Anyone else's opinion?

[timfinz]

I would hazard a guess of 3.5 IMHO! The book does appear to be generally worn and the missing corner and interior pages does not provide a stronger case to grade any higher.

[JollyComics]

Methink 1.8 is too harsh.

 

I had ST #110 with the similar defect as your book but there is a small missing chuck.

 

My book was graded 3.5 so I bet your book would be 2.5 to 3.0. Play it safe at Good+ to Good/Very Good (GD+ to GD/VG).

[mcnick]

Thanks to everyone so far for their opinions!