PGM Captain America #123

[Thegula]

Hey Everyone!

Last up for the day

Captain America #123.

Probably the best of the Caps of my haul from yesterday.

Front

Back

More tomorrow!

Thanks again!!!!

[timfinz]

4.0 IMHO! CGC might hammer it a little more because of the staining. I don't think the staining is overly obtrusive so I gave it the grade that I felt it was worthy of!

[Mijael.Levy]

So a stain is very bad deffect ? I mean if i see a stain the book should fall to VG grades? Because if it wasn´t for the stain i would say that it looks like a 6.5 or 7.0

[tjanse]

So a stain is very bad deffect ? I mean if i see a stain the book should fall to VG grades? Because if it wasn´t for the stain i would say that it looks like a 6.5 or 7.0

 

Every book is different no one set guideline on a stain. Atleast I don't think so.

Things that I factor in a stain

Can it be cleaned off?(like a buger stain)

How big is the stain?

How many pages does the stain go though?

Type of stain?

Water? Oil? Smoke fire?

I think a water stain is a stain I can live with over a oil stain.

 

This book has slight water damage I'm guessing.

 

Got wet

They cleaned off the cover and put a piece paper behind the cover to keep from hurting inside pages.

Wiped off the back. But then laid it back down n the back cover. Thinking it was dry left it as such. Then came back and realized it wasn't dry on back. That why you see the staining on the lower back right corner. I'm guessing some kinda transfer from table was layin on.

 

I'd say 4.0 seems good