PGM Fantastic Four #51 (Copy B)

[vaillant]

Last one for today… (thumbs u

 

Would be a quite nice copy if not for the spine creasing, which leaves me a bit undecided…

This is becoming my keeper anyway…

 

Images can be clicked to see larger versions.

 

Many thanks in advance as usual!

 

 

[makeminemego]

5.5. Great looking book with a great story.

[Scturo]

6.0/6.5, spine crease and left front corners.

[vaillant]

Many thanks!

I think that by CGC standards the spine creases are a bit too extended to allow for a FN+, are there some expert grader to confirm this?

[timfinz]

5.0 IMHO! Great looking copy but between the spine wear, staple tear and impact damage at the bottom of the front cover I don't think I would grade this copy any higher. Others I'm sure will disagree.

[vaillant]

Please some other grade!

[Lennart76]

Im for 5.0/5.5!

[Phill the Governor]

5.5 all day long. Maybe a 6.0

[vaillant]

I think the 5.0 votes are mostly for the long-running creases. With creases of that length I don’t think CGC standards allow for a 6.0 but thank you!

[JollyComics]

I think the 5.0 votes are mostly for the long-running creases. With creases of that length I don’t think CGC standards allow for a 6.0 but thank you!

 

Probably yes.

[HighStakesComics]

Very nice 5.5, with an outside shot at 6.0. Nicer than 5.0 IMHO

[cpannell]

Very nice 5.5, with an outside shot at 6.0. Nicer than 5.0 IMHO

 

Yes, 5.5 was what I thought before looking at anyone else's grades.

 

Nice copy.