Guess the Grades on my latest CGC submission

[143ksk]

I just got these back from CGC so thought I would post them for a quick round of "Guess the Grade." I will post the answers Sunday.

 

Terrors of the Jungle #21 Classic LB Cole cover

 

 

Tip Top #185 First Peanuts cover

 

 

Wonder Woman #200 Amazing Jeff Jones cover

 

[Silver Surfer]

9.2

9.2

9.4

[burntboy]

9.2

9.2

9.4

 

i hope for my team contest teammate's sake, you're right, but i'm thinking a tad lower across the board.

 

8.5 that half-inch LRC crease and the major discoloration of the back cover.

8.0 spine has lot's of nicks, and there are tiny chips out of the ULC/LRC BC

9.2 very nice and except for the slight blunting of the LRC, can't see much else wrong, but it's a square bound (of sorts) and much newer.

 

a VERY LOVELY little eclectic group

[blutobc]

Terrors of Jungle - 9.0 - nice book

 

Top Top - 8.0 possible 7.5

 

Wonder Woman - 9.2

[uclapeterg]

8.0

 

7.5

 

9.4

[Artboy99]

8.5 soiled back cover, stress on spine blunted corner

8.0

7.0 Bc spine crease that also shows on front cover LRFC looks blunted too

 

Artboy99

[namisgr]

8.0

7.5

9.2

[LastStarfighter]

8.0 Wow, Great book

 

7.0 Spine stresses, but otherwise a great copy

 

9.4 This book looks great.

[DiceX]

8.5

7.5

9.2

[october]

7.5 (great book, but I think the tanning drops it below 8.5)

7.0

9.2

[Murph]

#1 - 9.0

#2 - 7.5

#3 - 9.2

[divad]

8.0 soiled BC; spine creasing; 3/8" crease LRFC

 

6.5 The top staple crack is a killer in my book; tiny chip to ULBC

 

9.2 But I could see a 9.4, even with that double-sided nut sack crease

 

[uclapeterg]

8.0 soiled BC; spine creasing; 3/8" crease LRFC

 

6.5 The top staple crack is a killer in my book; tiny chip to ULBC

 

9.2 But I could see a 9.4, even with that double-sided nut sack crease

 

 

You don't have to cop an attitude!

[nik]

1. 8.0

2. 7.0

3 9.2

[joeno3]

7.5

 

8.0

 

8.5

 

NICE BOOKS

[Kermit the frog]

it's very interesting to see the "big gaps" between each one of the members grade evaluation...very nice small lot, congrats!

[inconceivable]

Terror's of the Jungle 9.0 (VF/NM) just a little spine stress and a LRFC crease

Tip Top 7.0 (F/VF) Tear at top staple and chip out of back cover

Wonder Woman 9.4 (NM) Just a little wear at the bottom left corner front cover

 

Great books.

Dan

[Comicdey]

8

 

6.5

 

9.0

[Comicdey]

How do I change the just got here (even though i did) and how can I post up some nice scans? Where's the thread to teach a newbie?

 

Thanks in advance.

[Shield]

I got all excited thinking I was going to see some MLJ subs...