PGM GSXM1

[amnesiac]

Hey guys. Havent subbed too many of these and by too many I mean none. This copy is very VERY nice and the only thing thats troubling me is the tiny hold next to Nightcrawler. Its from the bottom staple. Without it I would put this firmly in the 9s with a good press, but with it I have no clue. Any insight would be greatly appreciated folks. -A

 

 

[Humantop]

8.5

[amnesiac]

8.5

 

Yeah???

[Sauce Dog]

Errr...I don't think 8.5, comparing it (assuming a pressing) to my 8.0 they look very close except yours has that staple issue which i'm not sure how it would impact the grade. Safe bet, assume 8.0

[ItsJustRyan]

8.0

[Ccmp99]

7.5 - 8.0. square bounds are weird

[amnesiac]

Good deal guys. Thanks for the insight!!!

[The-Collector]

As it is I see 8.5, with potential to go higher. I have seen a 9.6 with a staple hole it is very common on square bounds. The rippling along the spine is also common and CGC treats it leniently on GSX1. Your example is relatively minor compared to others.

[Doktor]

much nicer copy than my 6.5. I think it's probably a solid 8-8.5

[Humantop]

8.5

 

Yeah???

 

I feel a 8,5 as the staple marks may nor affect that much of a grade.

[jhutton2]

A press would help this a lot. Bottom front right corner would still be a concern, but it should still grade well even with that. Potential for a 9+ grade here depending upon how that front corner presses out.

 

Good luck.

[JollyComics]

This book will be graded somewhere between 8.0 and 9.2.

[timfinz]

9.0 IMHO!