2015 March Madness Comic Grading Tournament - Round of 32

[Comicdey]

ANSWER KEY

 

 

Yikes, I thought I over graded the first two as 8.5 and 9.0.

Me too!

 

 

Kinda tough round for me...

 

GL 87 8.5 (was thinking as low as a 7.5 and then as high as 9.0). Really 9.0 ack

 

MP 1 9.0 (leaning towards a higher 9.2, I had a 9.2 once.....sold it....ack). Really. 9.2. Ack

 

MT 100 6.0 (had it preliminary at 6.5 and then thought 6.0-5.5, then landed at 5.5, and made a last second change to 6). Really 6.5 ack

 

ST 115 3.5 (each time I've graded that book, it landed at a 3.5 for many reasons) really 3.0. Ack

 

So I scored a 63. That's just wrong to be so close and pick wrong every time.

 

 

 

Ok....Grades are in

 

 

So now you all know my secret thought process

 

Am I in. Or am I out

[BlowUpTheMoon]

[ItsJustRyan]

You're in

[Boboset]

I went:

GL 8.5

MP 9.0

MT 6.0 This one was tough. Could not decide between 6.5 and 6.0. I choose poorly...

ST 3.0

 

 

[ItsJustRyan]

I had

 

9.0

8.5

5.5

2.0

 

 

Good luck Comicdey (thumbs u

 

 

Go get 'em

[sckao]

rjpb should be marmat right?

Nevermind... Hadn't updated the Bracket Graphic Spreadsheet...

 

 

[Comicdey]

You're in

 

Thanks for having an off day

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Not only did we lose two #1 seeds, we lost last years winner.

[Comicdey]

I had

 

9.0

8.5

5.5

2.0

 

 

Good luck Comicdey (thumbs u

 

 

Go get 'em

 

Thanks

 

Swimming with the sharks. My score won't hold up unless I can raise em.

 

 

[Scturo]

too low on the GL and MT, congrats Mccollect. Good luck to the Sweet Sixteeners

[BlowUpTheMoon]

We have a little hiccup in this round of the Tournament.

 

Because of that pesky thing called work, I won't be able to accept grades between 4p and 11p.

 

I should be able to post the grades around 10p (EST).

 

So, grades are still due by 10p (EST).

 

This confuses me.

 

Rereading it confuses me too. I could have worded it much better.

[mccollect]

too low on the GL and MT, congrats Mccollect. Good luck to the Sweet Sixteeners

 

Thanks, I was nervous.

 

 

[Wilson3d]

I am grading lower this year. Good game everyone! I'm out.

[toro]

Wow, Unca Scrooge hits a 3 pointer at the buzzer to pull off the upset and sink the Shark. (okay, I've watched too many NCAA games these past two days)

 

That was a nice match up.

[B3AST]

Had

 

GL 8.0

MP 8.5

MT 7.0

ST 3.5

 

Horseshoed all around the grades no bulls-eyes. I didnt think there was any way the MP was in the 9s with all the spin ticks and didn't think the GL was as good as the MP. thus the 8.0

Congrats drewincanada.

[Still Only 35c]

I'm gone. No direct hits this time, had...

 

GL 9.2

MP 9.0

MT 5.5

ST 2.5

 

Just happy to have made last 32 in my inaugural year in the tournament. Good luck to Toro in the next round.

 

BTW, did anyone else notice the mark on Hulks leg on the MP1? What was that?

 

[LordRahl]

I'm gone. No direct hits this time, had...

 

GL 9.2

MP 9.0

MT 5.5

ST 2.5

 

Just happy to have made last 32 in my inaugural year in the tournament. Good luck to Toro in the next round.

 

BTW, did anyone else notice the mark on Hulks leg on the MP1? What was that?

 

Noticed it and assumed print flaw

[drewincanada]

We have a little hiccup in this round of the Tournament.

 

Because of that pesky thing called work, I won't be able to accept grades between 4p and 11p.

 

I should be able to post the grades around 10p (EST).

 

So, grades are still due by 10p (EST).

 

This confuses me.

 

Rereading it confuses me too. I could have worded it much better.

 

You should have just said "These are not the grades you're looking for."

[drewincanada]

Had

 

GL 8.0

MP 8.5

MT 7.0

ST 3.5

 

Horseshoed all around the grades no bulls-eyes. I didnt think there was any way the MP was in the 9s with all the spin ticks and didn't think the GL was as good as the MP. thus the 8.0

Congrats drewincanada.

 

Thanks B3AST. Tough, tough round for everyone. I was with you on the MP. But I thought the GL was considerably better than the MP.

 

GL 9.2

MP 8.5

MT 6.0

ST 3.0

[Hado]

Crud

 

I was over, under, under, over.

 

Good luck Iceman, and thanks to everyone who makes this a great event on the board calendar.