Two Edgar Church copies of the same comic? 1 1

[rob_react]

I don't believe I've ever held a raw Church book.

 

I bought a cheap one just to own it.

 

I don't have a good sense of smell but some guys roll their eyes in the back of their heads when they do it, apparently it's that good.

 

Not saying they can't be manufactured, but there is more to the Church pedigree than just penciled codes (and that goes for many pedigrees - many of them have distinctive smells based on how the books were stored - for example, half of the Big Apple Pedigree smells like kerosene because the room the books were stored in smelled like kerosene). You might be able to slip one by a novice but someone who knows their Pedigrees is more likely to catch them.

 

 

I've had some cheap raw copies in addition to the slabbed copies I've had over the years. The smell is distinctive.

[VintageComics]

FU, Roy

 

Before or after dinner?

[vaillant]

FU, Roy

Now you sound like a broken record.

[VintageComics]

FU, Roy

Now you sound like a broken record.

 

Don't get on his good side, he might start sending you creepy PMs.

 

[slym2none]

I've never gotten a creepy PM from Greggy...

 

 

I was just happy when, after a couple years, he finally acknowledged me with a nice "suck it" one time.

 

 

 

 

-slym

[MrBedrock]

I don't believe I've ever held a raw Church book.

 

I bought a cheap one just to own it.

 

I don't have a good sense of smell but some guys roll their eyes in the back of their heads when they do it, apparently it's that good.

 

Not saying they can't be manufactured, but there is more to the Church pedigree than just penciled codes (and that goes for many pedigrees - many of them have distinctive smells based on how the books were stored - for example, half of the Big Apple Pedigree smells like kerosene because the room the books were stored in smelled like kerosene). You might be able to slip one by a novice but someone who knows their Pedigrees is more likely to catch them.

 

 

I've had some cheap raw copies in addition to the slabbed copies I've had over the years. The smell is distinctive.

Most of the Hawkeye collection smells like mothballs.

[Sqeggs]

I don't believe I've ever held a raw Church book.

 

I bought a cheap one just to own it.

 

I don't have a good sense of smell but some guys roll their eyes in the back of their heads when they do it, apparently it's that good.

 

Not saying they can't be manufactured, but there is more to the Church pedigree than just penciled codes (and that goes for many pedigrees - many of them have distinctive smells based on how the books were stored - for example, half of the Big Apple Pedigree smells like kerosene because the room the books were stored in smelled like kerosene). You might be able to slip one by a novice but someone who knows their Pedigrees is more likely to catch them.

 

 

I've had some cheap raw copies in addition to the slabbed copies I've had over the years. The smell is distinctive.

Most of the Hawkeye collection smells like mothballs.

 

[Walla Walla]

I also have a Don Winslow #34 which is a Church copy CGC #1004451012

Will post a picture tomorrow itis a 9.6

[kav]

I propose this would be impossible:

[BlowUpTheMoon]

[kav]

9 minutes ago, BlowUpTheMoon said:

Um a 4.0 Church book?  

[BlowUpTheMoon]

The 4.0 may have not been a Church book.