YOU VERSUS CGC - Part III: Strange Mysteries #1

[Soft-Serve]

PART III:

 

Folks seem to like the game, so let's continue....Here is my original disclaimer for new players:

 

" I've noticed that a lot of folks have had guesses wildly different from CGC results and decided to start a series of posts to help close the gap. At any rate, it should be fun to see how close you are.

Disclaimer: My collection is primarily golden age, so that is what I'll be posting by-and-large, although I have (had) a handful of Silver keys that I'll post for fun.

All of the books I post here are former-CGC books (because that's the way I like'em) and I will provide high resolution scans of the raw book and, after at least 10 15 guesses, I will post the label. Grades vary from low to high. "

Links to earlier parts:

Part I: Exciting Comics #57

Part II: Ka'anga #11

Part III: Strange Mysteries #1

Part IV: Planet comics #62

 

 

 

 

The real grade is......(no changing your guesses!)

 

 

 

And Now: Strange Mysteries #1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Conan_Aficionado]

5.5

[427Impaler]

5.0

[Shizzlemetimbers]

7.0

[DeadOne]

5.5

[FineCollector]

5.0

[HighStakesComics]

6.5

[Point Five]

5.5 seems about right. Awesome cover!

 

 

[divad]

I like both the high and low grades for this book . . .

[porcupine48]

If those are tears on the bottom back cover...5.0

[thunsicker]

6.5. Looks much nicer from the front.

[Shadow]

6.0 trying to balance the nicer looking front with the back.

[1Cool]

Love these books since I never know how to grade a great looking front with pretty much all the defects on back. I'm going 6.0.

[Matches_Malone]

6.0

[Soft-Serve]

 

aaaaaand the real grade is......(no changing your guesses!)

 

 

 

 

 

 

Part IV coming soon.....

 

Links to earlier parts:

Part I: Exciting Comics #57

Part II: Ka'anga #11

Part III: Strange Mysteries #1

Part IV: Planet Comics #62

Part V: Wonder Comics #12

[DeadOne]

[Azkaban]

Just saw this one, would have went with a 5.0 Congrats