Which one would you choose, and why?

[showcase4]

Both sold at auction recently for a approx. $48,500 ~~~ which one would you choose, and why??

[Beardown]

Amazing fantasy 15 for me.

 

That being said X-men 1 is a very important book and one I'd love to own but in this case the nod goes to spider-man for me.

[catrick339]

AF 15.

 

MUCH scarcer book, X-Men 1's are thick on the ground. All it takes is a pile of cash to snag one.

 

AF 15, on the other hand is seldom seen this nice, I'm thinking.

[oakman29]

How many places are you posting this?

[BarryAllen]

[Gotham Kid]

I'd take the AF15.

[Waylander]

Both

[jimjum12]

For 50K ?.........neither. GOD BLESS...

 

-jimbo(a friend of jesus)

[namisgr]

For 50K ?.........neither. GOD BLESS...

 

-jimbo(a friend of jesus)

 

+1

 

For that much, it should be possible to find nicer looking examples in those grades.

[lou_fine]

Both

 

Yes, indeed!

 

For that much money, it would have to be both of them.

[Ken Aldred]

For 50K ?.........neither. GOD BLESS...

 

-jimbo(a friend of jesus)

 

+1

 

For that much, it should be possible to find nicer looking examples in those grades.

 

+1

 

Neither, although a bit theoretical and too rich for me, anyway.

 

Fairly weak examples, presentation-wise.

[makeminemego]

For 70K, I'd pass on both.

 

If I had to spend 70K on either of the books, I'd say "no thanks" and buy 3 AF 15s in the 4.0-5.0 range. I'd look for copies that presented better relatively than the one listed does, with better PQ as well.

[Whitelanterncorps]

If someone offered to give me one or the other, I'd take the AF 15.