Another AM 15 scam sort of

[drotto]

cracked slabbed and re-graded by you know who.

 

original sale

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Amazing-Fantasy-15-CGC-5-1st-Spider-Man-Key-Holy-Grail-Lee-Marvel-1962-Rare-/152314416081?hash=item2376a58bd1%3Ag%3AyT0AAOSwXeJYJfOW&nma=true&si=Qnc0GRZDW7fVr2N4HK6D4VjOtOg%253D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557

 

Now in new slab PGX so no big surprise.

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Amazing-Fantasy-15-Vol-1-PGX-1-5-Nice-Unrestored-1st-App-of-Spider-Man-1962-/401248022304?hash=item5d6c3eef20:g:XksAAOSwa~BYTY47

[Lethal_Collector]

I see the same listing twice?

 

 

Jerome

[Hado]

The links take me to the same page

[kav]

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Amazing-Fantasy-15-Vol-1-PGX-1-5-Nice-Unrestored-1st-App-of-Spider-Man-1962-/401248022304?hash=item5d6c3eef20:g:XksAAOSwa~BYTY47

[drotto]

fixed it now sorry. Looks like it was cleaned and pressed but it is the same book.

[Paddy_McShillihan]

Just bought a book off allthingscomics ... are they no good ?

[Paddy_McShillihan]

Damn I should have searched them on here ... normally I do ..

 

Thought the name sounded familiar

[exitmusicblue]

Shouldn't this guy get impaled on a set of pitchforks or something?

[Paddy_McShillihan]

I guess I'm checking thoroughly for color touch .... best ways to do that ?

[Lethal_Collector]

I guess I'm checking thoroughly for color touch .... best ways to do that ?

 

Blacklight. Otherwise, it's pretty tough without it in person.

 

 

Jerome

[mattn792]

Wow, it's complete with a good amount of the cover intact, and not on fire. Figured PGX would give it at least a 4.5...

[1950's war comics]

Not a scam just a resub to brand ecch, actually pretty lucrative move for the seller if the sale goes through....

[woowoo]

CGC CBCS PGX everyone grades diff. CGC is real tight CBCS/PGX are not as tight. I would say after press it should be 1.0

[budsbundy]

I guess I'm checking thoroughly for color touch .... best ways to do that ?

These guys are the kings of trimming

That's what I'd be looking for

[rjpb]

CGC CBCS PGX everyone grades diff. CGC is real tight CBCS/PGX are not as tight. I would say after press it should be 1.0

 

 

The press did approve the appearance some, but it's still a complete beater. One of those books on the PR/FR bubble due to it mostly all still being there and not completely brittle.

 

I've got no argument with pressing it and calling it a soft 1.0, but 1.5 is typical PGX overgrade on the low end , and since when is that Good- ? Considering I've seen PGX give taped up beaters missing pages as high as a 2.5, I'm not surprised though.

 

 

[Paddy_McShillihan]

I guess I'm checking thoroughly for color touch .... best ways to do that ?

These guys are the kings of trimming

That's what I'd be looking for

 

 

 

Now that I look at it it kind of looks trimmed at the bottom ... but I'd have no idea if it really is

[woowoo]

CGC CBCS PGX everyone grades diff. CGC is real tight CBCS/PGX are not as tight. I would say after press it should be 1.0

 

 

The press did approve the appearance some, but it's still a complete beater. One of those books on the PR/FR bubble due to it mostly all still being there and not completely brittle.

 

I've got no argument with pressing it and calling it a soft 1.0, but 1.5 is typical PGX overgrade on the low end , and since when is that Good- ? Considering I've seen PGX give taped up beaters missing pages as high as a 2.5, I'm not surprised though.

 

 

They gave my Hulk 1 a 1.5 grade and i bought as a 3.0 so it workd both ways. I sent you pm of the book and its way better than this 1.5 fantasy 15

I feel like i got a bad grade after seeing that book.

[D800Model0325]

If that guy is a scammer then that's a shame. I was about to buy a CGC SS hulk 1 from him. He does have an impressive list of books for sale every once in a while.

[Dark Knight]

I knew it had something to do with all_things_comics. Seller has had a bad rep selling comics. There should be a number of threads about the seller on here if you research it. Just stay away to sum it up..

[D800Model0325]

Because he's local from where I live I considered doing business with him. But after reading this has caught my attention. Anybody with a bad experience with him would like to share their story?