PGM Batman The Killing Joke 1st Print 0

[drotto]

This one looks almost flawless to me.

[davet75]

slightly rounded corners, but otherwise flawless

CGC 9.4

[theCapraAegagrus]

7 hours ago, davet75 said:

slightly rounded corners, but otherwise flawless

CGC 9.4

Agreed.

[drotto]

I not why the scans make the corners look rounded ( I see it), in person they are sharp. 

[KobaltDog]

If the corners are sharp then 9.6 from me. 9.4 if the corners appear rounded in person.

[timfinz]

Provided there are no hidden indents, blemishes or finger imprints on the black covers anywhere I can't see anything that would hold this back.

Spoiler

9.8 IMHO

 

[Ahsoka Tano Jedi Apprentice]

is this a 1 owner book ?   9.6

[GregHa]

9.2

[ComicsAndCode]

Sharp copy. Based on the two images, a 9.6. Though would be helpful to see side shot of the book for better view of the binding.

[drotto]

Ok pictures of corners.  Maybe a little tick ( looks production) on one.

[ComicsAndCode]

Hmm, very few blemishes, the TLH corner being the most significant. Will say 9.4  maybe 9.6

[Ahsoka Tano Jedi Apprentice]

i have 20 of these and i have only opened one of them and read it.  Those line frays on the edges are all production. All copies are not made equal but if they are not read ( and you can tell by looking at it )  they won't  protrude the binder line along the crease and in that case they should nearly always be a 9.6   They can get scratches just from the shipping process to your comic shop and going on display in the store.   I have not had any of them graded yet but am interested  how CGC would grade like 19 of these that have never been opened or read. I bagged and bordered them the day they came out and they have been sitting in a box ever since. The question being will C.G.C. nit pick to death the copies with little  production flaws.. I would think it's nit pick to death time if i submitted them. Granted half are semi pristine but it's the other half with production flaws i'm worries about.