How does Overstreet note IH180 and 181? 0

[miraclemet]

Those of you with copies of old Overstreet Price Guides, how do they notate IH180/181?

Did it list one or the other as Wolverines 1st appearance? 

Did it change at some point? Or has it always been the same.

Note: sweet saasy molassy I dont want to kick off another IH180/181 argument. Just want to know how Overstreet has noted it thru the years...

[Arkham]

Volume 46 (2016/2017) lists: 

* IH180 - 1st brief app. Wolverine (last pg.)

* IH181 - 1st full Wolverine story; Trimpe-a

I'd tell you what my older copies said.. but in a fit of foolishness and having issues with space, I got rid of them. One of several things I'd do differently today. 

@Wall-Crawler - you picked up an old copy recently didn't you?  What does it say in that? 

Edited May 21, 2021 by Arkham
Add Vol 46 coverage year.

[marvelmaniac]

From Volume 38, 2008...

[Wall-Crawler]

10 hours ago, Arkham said:

Volume 46 (2016/2017) lists: 

* IH180 - 1st brief app. Wolverine (last pg.)

* IH181 - 1st full Wolverine story; Trimpe-a

I'd tell you what my older copies said.. but in a fit of foolishness and having issues with space, I got rid of them. One of several things I'd do differently today. 

@Wall-Crawler - you picked up an old copy recently didn't you?  What does it say in that? 

My reprint of OSPG 1st edition is before they were published, but my OSPG #12 circa 1982-83 states:

IH #180 1st appearance Wolverine (cameo) NM price: $6.00

IH #181 Wolverine appearance NM price: $16.00

[serling1978]

14 minutes ago, Wall-Crawler said:

My reprint of OSPG 1st edition is before they were published, but my OSPG #12 circa 1982-83 states:

IH #180 1st appearance Wolverine (cameo) NM price: $6.00

IH #181 Wolverine appearance NM price: $16.00

$16? I don't know.... I'd wait around for a deal... 

[Arkham]

Genuinely interesting to see this change over time! 

[lou_fine]

5 hours ago, Sofa King 👑 said:

OPG #9 and then OPG #20.

 

WTF:  Are you sure this is right and it's from OPG 9 or 1979?  

If so, looks like I really got hosed on my copy by the dealer since I paid what is obviously a stratospheric price at the time then of $5 for my top row minty fresh wall copy at the local comic con back in the day.       

[lou_fine]

5 minutes ago, Sofa King 👑 said:

 

Most definitely, although it might have actually been into the very early 80's because I sincerely doubt that I would have been willing to pay that kind of ridiculous multiple to top of guide for a book like that at the time.  

It's too bad they don't give out receipts although I am not sure what their return policy would be anyways and highly doubt they would be willing to give you a full refund right after completely hosing you for your hard earned $5.        

[Larryw7]

When I went to the Creation con in Philly in 1979, Jay Maybruck told me he was buying GS1 and XM 94 for 25 bucks apiece. I said that they were cheap in the Guide, and Jay said that the guide is wrong on a lot of books. At that time I treated it like a Bible.

[Mr bla bla]

15 hours ago, Sofa King 👑 said:

OPG #9 and then OPG #20.

So the 1st app. is indeed IH 180 👍

[Chaykin Stevens]

21 hours ago, marvelmaniac said:

Strange that they bother to mention the Trimpe art on #181.  Didn't he draw most issues for about eight years?

[csaag]

19 hours ago, serling1978 said:

$16? I don't know.... I'd wait around for a deal... 

That price makes sense.  I remember buying mine from my LCS back in the early 80's for about $20

[Jeffro.]

6 hours ago, Mr bla bla said:

So the 1st app. is indeed IH 180

It always was, regardless of what Overstreet said. All you have to do is look at the last page of IH 180 to know that. 

[mattn792]

7 hours ago, Larryw7 said:

When I went to the Creation con in Philly in 1979, Jay Maybruck told me he was buying GS1 and XM 94 for 25 bucks apiece. I said that they were cheap in the Guide, and Jay said that the guide is wrong on a lot of books. At that time I treated it like a Bible.

Such a coincidence, I’m currently looking to buy GS1 and X-Men 94 for $25 apiece too!

[KirbyJack]

I bought my GSXM 1 for $50. 
I’d feel cheated if I hadn’t almost doubled my money when I sold it to a LCS.

Edited May 22, 2021 by KirbyJack

[Hibou]

On 5/21/2021 at 12:07 AM, miraclemet said:

Those of you with copies of old Overstreet Price Guides, how do they notate IH180/181?

Did it list one or the other as Wolverines 1st appearance? 

Did it change at some point? Or has it always been the same.

Note: sweet saasy molassy I dont want to kick off another IH180/181 argument. Just want to know how Overstreet has noted it thru the years...

Just saw this...

 

 

[Juno Beach]

Lol, #182 1st (and last) Crackjack Jackson.

[Lazyboy]

19 hours ago, Mr bla bla said:

On 5/21/2021 at 10:25 AM, Sofa King 👑 said:

 

 

So the 1st app. is indeed IH 180 👍

I must be missing something.

Of course it is, even if it's brief and essentially only an ad for the next issue.

[bronze johnny]

On 5/21/2021 at 12:07 AM, miraclemet said:

Those of you with copies of old Overstreet Price Guides, how do they notate IH180/181?

Did it list one or the other as Wolverines 1st appearance? 

Did it change at some point? Or has it always been the same.

Note: sweet saasy molassy I dont want to kick off another IH180/181 argument. Just want to know how Overstreet has noted it thru the years...

This would make for a good thread on how Overstreet has adjusted notations for many books throughout the decades.