2022 CGC Grading Contest Season 1 Fall Edition (#4) Round 4 8 8

[CGC Mike]

This round is closed.  Books coming up in a few...

[CGC Mike]

[CGC Mike]

Big 3 #7

Writing center of back cover

Small piece out left top of back cover

Piece out right bottom of back cover

Moderate creasing to cover

Cover tanning

Staining to cover

 

Dynamic Comics #11

Multiple water stain center of front cover

Multiple water stain right center of front cover

Small spine split bottom of spine

Staple tears

Multiple stain top of back cover

Chip out right bottom of front cover

Cover tanning

 

Detective #312

Water stain entire spine

Light staple tears

Staple rust

Stain right bottom through whole book

 

Fantastic Four #48

Multiple crease with small tear left bottom of back cover

Multiple crease right top of front cover breaks color

Multiple crease right bottom of front cover breaks color

Wear all corners of cover

Star Spangled War Stories #51

Medium crease center of front cover breaks color

Small, multiple scuff right bottom of front cover

Stain right bottom of front cover

Light foxing to cover

[grendelbo]

I did alright this round.

Thanks for the contest and your effort, Mike.

[g-man]

Lots of fun….did ok this round. 1 🎯….can’t believe the SSWS w a sub crease realized a 6.5! 
thanks Mike. 

[musicmeta]

Best round yet for me.  One bullseye with a total of 5 points.  I'll take it. 

[comicginger1789]

Nailed Big 3

Had the grades swapped on the next two (went 5.5 and 4.5 instead of the way they were), nailed the FF and was 0.5 over on the last one.

5 points, best round 

[WilliamLunt]

Tough Round, congrats to the (eventual) winners!

[CGC Mike]

If you sent in your grades today and haven't received confirmation from me, that is because I haven't recorded your grades yet.  If you sent in your grades prior to today and have not received confirmation from me, please bump our PM.  I had a few people's grades disappear from the spreadsheet.  Hopefully, there is no more.  When we get the results and there are some people's grades missing, just let me know and they will be added.  

[jcjames]

[zzutak]

Only a 6.5 for a book with a color-breaking subscription crease and moisture stains?    Why not a 7.0 or 7.5 (or even or 8.0)??? 

[Axelrod]

I very consistently over-graded every book!

Take 1/2 off every grade and it's a 3.  As it is, I think it's like 8 points.

[Warlord]

 

[frozentundraguy]

Two bullseyes and only 5 points this round

[Crose87420]

I think...I think I got hit for 18 points in that round...I must have had too many Bud Lights? I got a bull on the first book and then missed the next two by 5 grades each and the next two by 4 grades each...do I get a discount on the new grading guide from CGC for finishing in last?

[universal soldier]

[ADAMANTIUM]

 

6 Greeny Deeny Points, my best round YET!! This go around, best wishes for everyone!  

[thehumantorch]

ugh, my worst round ever.  sob 

[Superman2006]

Thanks for all your work facilitating another awesome contest, Mike! 

With a 4 in that round, I'm optimistic that I'll be able to three-peat as a top 10 finisher. If so, I'll gladly take that result since they're the first three grading contests I've ever participated in (I just missed the deadline for signing up for the inaugural CGC contest).

[Comics4All]

2 

for me this round!

Thanks @CGC Mike for putting this together! 

Edited November 13, 2022 by Comics4All