Need help from tick collectors!has cgc made an error? 2 2

[Namtak]

Got this great tick 4...the thing is that it seems to me to be an original but cgc labels it as a chroma tick 1992.....need help here,is there a chroma tick like mine cause the ones i know says color!on the cover.has cgc made an error?

[manetteska]

On 1/17/2023 at 6:16 PM, Namtak said:

Got this great tick 4...the thing is that it seems to me to be an original but cgc labels it as a chroma tick 1992.....need help here,is there a chroma tick like mine cause the ones i know says color!on the cover.has cgc made an error?

Looks like the first run #4 to me.

Here is a Chroma-Tick #4; similar but definitely different enough to label correctly:

[ttfitz]

On 1/17/2023 at 8:57 PM, manetteska said:

Here is a Chroma-Tick #4; similar but definitely different enough to label correctly:

I don't know, it only says "Chroma-Tick" at the top instead of "Tick", and it only has the word "Color" 3 times on the cover. Well, and a completely different price.  So kinda a judgement call, I'd say.

[manetteska]

On 1/18/2023 at 3:44 PM, ttfitz said:

I don't know, it only says "Chroma-Tick" at the top instead of "Tick", and it only has the word "Color" 3 times on the cover. Well, and a completely different price.  So kinda a judgement call, I'd say.

Comic professionals!

[THE_BEYONDER]

[Poutine]

Might be a first print. This is the 8th, note price difference 

 

Edited January 18, 2023 by James' Honey Pot

[Brian Bollinger]

On 1/17/2023 at 7:16 PM, Namtak said:

Got this great tick 4...the thing is that it seems to me to be an original but cgc labels it as a chroma tick 1992.....need help here,is there a chroma tick like mine cause the ones i know says color!on the cover.has cgc made an error?

It's definitely mislabeled.  CGC has relabeled items for me for free (that I had CGCd) that had been mislabeled.  It won't mess up a personal collection as anyone can clearly see what comic book it actually is... BUT if someone is using the CGC registry to track their comics it will show up as the wrong comic.  So, while it will not change the value of the comic, it will change how it is able to be tracked.

[Browns81]

This should be noted as 1st Arthur and 1st Paul the Samurai.  At least for Arthur as he’s one of the main characters.