Action Comics 869 Beer Bottle Recall 1 1

[MutantMike]

I got this for $90, guy stated "NM" but I think it is VF to VF+ as best. Before I proceed just wanted some pro opinions.

 

 

 

[bronzemarvel]

You've highlighted some of the issues in your images, of course. That bottom right front corner and the quality of the back cover alone are keeping this from NM. Front top left corner and lower spine (color loss) are just piling on. I think you could be right with your 8.0 to 8.5, but I wonder if CGC would be more harsh given this is a modern comic.

[scburdet]

If the bottom of the BC has removable surface grime, *maybe* this gets to a 9.0. The fraying only the spine & the corners on the spine might not be treated too harshly if this issue has common production-related defects like this. Strictly speaking, a 7.5/8.0 is a safe grade. I would say it's taking a chance at CGC for something higher. Maybe, maybe not. If I was a buyer, I'd want a more clear cut case to pay NM prices.

[Brock]

7.5