Does CGC grade "Facsimile Cover Reprint" books? 2 2

[Okguy]

Does CGC grade "Facsimile Cover Reprint" books?  

Any examples of this? 

[Lightning55]

Just search eBay for any well known facsimile comic, with CGC in the title. If any appear in the results, you have your answer.

Or search the CGC registry by title.

[DougC]

On 4/30/2024 at 9:11 PM, Okguy said:

Does CGC grade "Facsimile Cover Reprint" books?  

Any examples of this? 

I believe you are asking if CGC will "grade" a coverless comic with a reprinted/facsimile front and back cover.

If so the answer is yes, it has to be attached at the staples but will receive a "NG" (no grade) designation when encapsulated.

[Sauce Dog]

Yes, I do it all the time - however it is better to source at least the back cover for these coverless books as that will allow you to obtain a 0.5 grade (at least half of the cover wrap must be present to qualify for a 0.5 grade, any more missing from a book and it is automatic NG).

This More Fun #72 has an entire facsimile cover wrap attached using the original staples.



However this Strange Tales #110 only has a facsimile for the front cover, the back cover is original.

Edited May 5 by Sauce Dog

[Sauce Dog]

Another example, facsimile front cover with an original back cover



Full facsimile cover wrap (as well as missing several interior wraps - basically the lowest of the low, but my options for owning such rare books is limited cause I don't earn that much, so I'll take what I can get)




 

Edited May 5 by Sauce Dog

[JollyComics]

OMG.