Guess the CGC grade: Superman #8

[Point Five]

Just for fun. Here's another slabbed GA Superman I've come across in my travels. (No back cover scan, but let's assume it's consistent or better than the front.) What grade do you think CGC gave it?

 

[MutantKeys]

Tough..Im guessing a 4.0

[thedude]

4.5

[Durden08]

Assuming it's unrestored, I'd say it looks like a 4.0

[Point Five]

Thanks for the guesses so far, troops!

 

And yep, blue label/unrestored, cream to OW pages, no label notes.

[BuckeyeChaos]

I'd guess 4.0

[blutobc]

I'd guess 4.5

 

with an outside chance of 5.0 with the GA bump factor.

[Psiknight]

I'm going to be optimistic and say 5.0 with the GA bump. It looks mighty nice!

[MutantKeys]

I put 2.5 by mistake instead of 4.5 and no one said anything

 

Taking a better look at it tough I say 4.0

[blutobc]

I put 2.5 by mistake instead of 4.5 and no one said anything

 

Taking a better look at it tough I say 4.0

 

No take backs.....

Besides you never know, you may be right.

[MutantKeys]

I put 2.5 by mistake instead of 4.5 and no one said anything

 

Taking a better look at it tough I say 4.0

 

No take backs.....

Besides you never know, you may be right.

 

Golden age is tough...sometimes you can be off..

[Timulty]

The Grading Bastiche says.....3.0. Yep, I don't agree this is a VG book.

[marvelcollector]

Based on the spine, I'd say it looks like a 4.5...

[Aces]

4.0 after the GA bump.

[comic_lot]

I agree, 4.0.

[sterlingcomics]

4.0

[Point Five]

Thanks for playing, guys! Here's the slabbed book so you can see for yourselves. To be quite honest, I probably would have guessed 3.5 to 4.0 on this book myself, with the slight chipping, staple wear and spine-area wear. You guys are good!

 

[MutantKeys]

 

Nice book..My original guess that was a typo and then changed and changed..

[Comicdey]

Just for fun. Here's another slabbed GA Superman I've come across in my travels. (No back cover scan, but let's assume it's consistent or better than the front.) What grade do you think CGC gave it?

 

 

Before reading the thread, I'm guessing 3.5 as it looks slightly brittle on the edges. Nice colors though.

 

Missed it by a 1/2 grade...

[-cryptkeeper-]

Thanks for playing, guys! Here's the slabbed book so you can see for yourselves. To be quite honest, I probably would have guessed 3.5 to 4.0 on this book myself, with the slight chipping, staple wear and spine-area wear. You guys are good!

 

 

i wasn't home 4.5 is a good deal

i would have said 3.5 but CGC rules