PGM Captain Midnight 17

[1Cool]

This issues doesn't have any hidden defects but the issue does have a small rip on the lower right cover and a split in the middle of the spine that goes through several pages. Thanks for the input.

 

[mdandy8]

Ugh, I love books like this: Overall it looks great, but somehow you have to factor in that spine split, gut tells me 4.0

 

anyone else?

[blutobc]

Nice war cover....

VG looks like the tops to me....that spine tear would make me go with a VG-

[Point Five]

3.5/4.0 was my first thought as well. Since the interior pages are affected by the tear, I'd lean 3.5 to be safe, but too many positives to go any lower. Nice one!

[Dr_Neff]

4.0

[1Cool]

I was actually leaning toward a 4.5 due to all the positives (just couldn't see a VG/FN). At least we are all in the same ballpark. Thanks!!