Lninefingers

I did precisely that on this round. Narrator: "He did not win this"

If the back cleans up, I think this gets to the 4.5/5.0 range

6.5 is too high for me, I think 5.0/5.5 range

I'll hop on the 5.5/6.0 train. Don't think it can push higher than that though

4.5ish, but presents well

Grades in!

Looks like a contender to me, but I'm going to guess just below at 9.4/9.6.

I got absolutely crushed by that book, but I like your standard for commenting and wouldn't change the way you do it.

Resist the urge! Stains are a death sentence: https://boards.cgccomics.com/topic/520963-pgm-iron-man-55-worth-an-appeal/

I was sure that was a stain on the back of the power girl book and treated it accordingly. 2 points otherwise, but 5 (yes, five) on that one kill me

Same. There were a couple where I could miss by 3 grades and not feel like either grade is unreasonable.

7ish

3.0 for me

This is really cool to see, thanks. Looks like I just missed the cut with only 16 rounds completed, but maybe if I can keep my head above water (dubious, given how I feel about this first round) this contest I can make the list next time.

I would like to retract my earlier complaints about too many golden age books. These books were not easy.