Hi everyone,
I have a question about graders notes. Today, I purchased graders notes on a Journey Into Mystery #83 that I own. It is a blue label 7.0 with the notation "small piece out of margin of last page" on the label.
I purchased the graders notes to obtain additional information about this piece such as its size, location, etc. The notes stated the following: Interior Piece Out" and "Left Top Back Cover Medium Light Crease".
I paid $15 for these notes and they told me nothing I did not already know. I feel like I was ripped off as this information is not worth the $15 I paid and was basically useless. I own over 300 CGC certified books and this is a definite disappointment.
I emailed this to CGC to see if I can obtain a refund of the $15 I paid as the blue label actually had more detail about the missing piece than the graders notes did.
Since the piece missing was accounted for in the 7.0 universal blue label, would this book have the same value as a 7.0 without the missing piece notation? The book is beautiful and would probably be an 8.5 without the missing piece.
Thanks for your help,
Jeff