silent06

Yes, both books were newsstand variants and the ASM 238 was supposed to be inclusive of the tatooz insert

Both GPA and GoCollect reference Ebay sales for their respective assessments of FMV, so I am not sure how you arrived at CGC providing and offering a valuation of 110% with taxes of current Ebay prices

Based on GPA, I would say the delta between their FMV estimate and CGC's is roughly 40% to 50%, which is still under what I paid for the books considering market value at the time, shipping costs, buyers premium, etc. However, I have attached a screenshot for you to make your own assessment. The books referenced by CGC in the screenshot were both purchased as holdered and believed to be a grade of 9.8

I, too, recently received emails for three of my four books affected by the tampering incident. It appears based on the offers provided by CGC that their analysis or assessment of "fair market value" is the actual or true grade of the book as part of this incident, not the grade as noted on the holder or as the consumer and original purchaser believed the book to be, which to me as someone impacted is unacceptable and in no way an attempt to make me whole. CGC seems to be playing with words such as "fair market value" to shroud their intent to make minimal disbursements for the claims in this incident.

Agreed. Outside of the validation of the certification number via the CGC verification site, CGC does not provide or outline any procedure or guidance for the consumer to inspect and discern or detect if the CGC holder or the contents within the holder have been tampered with, counterfeited or the contents of the book within the holder are in any way incomplete. Prior to this tampering incident, there wasn't even any statement regarding how a consumer or purchaser should take action if they suspected tamper or the contents of the holder had been altered in any way. The consumer or purchaser was standing on CGC's guarantee that the contents of the holder were authentic and unaltered based on the conveyance and trust of CGC's grading, holder and certification process.

The answer is yes that is correct to your questions on all accords. As well as the additional issue of the response I received from CGC of how they are addressing books that have been potentially tampered with, which were purchased directly from Mr. Zanello, but not included on the list as part in their announcement of the incident.

As one of those impacted, I can answer questions 1) and 2), based on the response I received from CGC. To question 1.) To my knowledge, the answer is Yes, the book has been surrendered and will be retained by CGC. With regards to question 2.) CGC has sighted that this incident is an ongoing investigation and that they do not have a confirmed date for the resolution of the claim. In alignment with the lack of any projected date for claim resolution, CGC has not provided any information regarding valuation or compensation for losses incurred for the books I purchased that were impacted by this incident.

I am just getting back in to collecting and only been back in the hobby about 6 months. However, personally, I wouldn't and don't want any books that were in the hands of the individual executing this fraud. There are actually a couple of books on ComicLink, while not the list, that are from his submissions and it has that fact alone has deterred me from entertaining bidding on them as we still don't fully know all the facets of his nefarious and fraudulent activities.

It does appear something has changed in their plan. This book which is struck through and has a new grade date is available on Heritage for sale. If the book has been cleared based on what CGC originally outlined it should have a new certification number and if not cleared should be in their hands as evidence based on the comments Matt Nelson provided in the recent discussion with West Davengers and 9.9 Newsstand. https://comics.ha.com/itm/the-amazing-spider-man-300-marvel-1988-cgc-nm-mt-98-white-pages/i/800110856.s?ic4=ListView-ShortDescription-071515

That confirms what I concluded as well. Being one of those impacted by this incident and fraud, I align with mrd160 as well as others who have commented and lent their countless effort and assistance in this whole debacle that any book that this individual came in contact with or crossed his hands should be listed for a thorough review with extreme prejudice and scrutiny in said review.

Some folks knowingly will try to get rid of these tampered 9.8's and pass on the problem to someone else... That's just wrong. Unless I am doing the query incorrectly, these two books correspond to submissions with books on the list. https://www.comiclink.com/auctions/item.asp?back=%2FAUCTIONS%2FSEARCH.ASP%3F_SORT%3DYES%26returning%3D1%26FocusedOnly%3D1%26where%3Dauctions%26title%3Damazing%2Bspider-man%26ItemType%3DCB%26GO%3DGO%26f1%3DCondition%26ODire1%3DDESC%26f2%3D4%2C%2BIssueNumber%2C%2BVolumeNumber%26ODire2%3DASC%26f3%3DLastUpdate%26ODire3%3DASC%26fshowpicture%3D1%26fthumbbeenhere%3D1%26freliststatus%3D%26pg%3D2%23Item_1742468&id=1742468&itemType=0#detail https://www.comiclink.com/auctions/item.asp?back=%2FAUCTIONS%2FSEARCH.ASP%3FFocusedOnly%3D1%26where%3Dauctions%26title%3Dx%2Dmen%26ItemType%3DCB%26pg%3D2%23Item_1742471&id=1742471&itemType=0

Yes, I purchased an IH340 that is on the list through ComicLink. https://www.comiclink.com/auctions/item.asp?back=%2FAUCTIONS%2FSEARCH.ASP%3F_SORT%3DYES%26returning%3D1%26FocusedOnly%3D1%26where%3Dauctions%26title%3Dincredible%2Bhulk%26ItemType%3DCB%26f1%3DCondition%26ODire1%3DDESC%26f2%3D4%2C%2BIssueNumber%2C%2BVolumeNumber%26ODire2%3DASC%26f3%3DLastUpdate%26ODire3%3DASC%26fshowpicture%3D1%26fthumbbeenhere%3D1%26freliststatus%3D%23Item_1728083&id=1728083&itemType=0#detail

Verified by whom? As one of the individuals impacted by this holder tampering incident, I raised this same question to CGC when the update to the announcement listing the books identified in the tampering incident was published as one of the books I purchased directly from briva3 was not included on the list. Below the response from their support Good morning. I am following up on behalf of Matthew to provide instructions to return books 4286817-003 and 4286977-001 for review. If your books are determined to be correctly graded, they will be reholdered with a new certification number and returned to you at no charge. If your book is determined to be incorrectly graded, our support team will contact you. If not already provided, you may be asked to submit certain additional documentation, such as the purchase receipt, as part of the review process. Please note that the submission history of 4329914-003 shows no evidence indicating that it is part of this incident. Instructions for Submitting an Eligible Book for Review Go to CGCcomics.com and sign in to your account or create a free account. You do not need to be a paid CGC member to submit an eligible comic book. Go to “Submission Forms” under “Submit” in the main menu. Choose the online submission form for Comics/Magazines and start a new order. Select your collectible type and then “Regular Grading Submission” and “Mail-In or Show Drop-Off.” Select “Holder Review” under “Special/Return Services” and enter all required information. There is no charge for this service (and all shipping fees will be paid by CGC) Print your packing slip and mail it along with your book to CGC. Write “HRV” on the outside of your shipping box. Thank you for your patience while we implemented a process to review any books affected by this incident. If you have any questions, please let us know. Thank you! Based on their response, my question is how they are confidently able to clear the book from the list solely based on submission history and scans without a physical inspection of the book specifically considering the book cleared is an ASM 238 that has an insert that could potentially be missing?

I say this rhetorically, but you have got to be kidding me. It is the same book that prompted this entire thread and the discussion that has ensued. This guy is no criminal mastermind, not even close to clever or cautious for that matter. https://www.ebay.com/itm/285589090234?hash=item427e6fafba:g:TIwAAOSwqwplbAkk

Based on what I have read in this thread and understand so far regarding the fraud and deception that are being used to execute this scam, my concern is that the ASM 238s I purchased are possibly either green label qualified books that do not contain the tattoos or have had the tattoos married to the book to create the ASM 238 Newsstands containing the tattoos, Not sure sure if the books used are truly 9.8s of some variation of the books I just mentioned as after he creates them and sends it to CGC the scans of his created 9.8 are what show up on CGC site when you query the certification number on the CGC cert verification website