romanheart

Has anyone ever bought a comic of lesser $ value because they liked the grade of the book better over that of a similar copy that was graded higher? You should see the expression on some dealers when you buy their cheaper copy because you think it has fewer flaws.

Maybe 10-15% of the time I would say a book is 9.8 or 9.6 and agree with CGC, IMO they are overly strict and grading is so subjective. I think a lot of people really are paying for the number.

If you have the money, then go ahead and pay for it. I like nice things too but you aren't necessarily getting a superior book.

I think you’re grading system and CGCs’ are different. Their grading system is strict. It takes a bit of practice to figure out but once you understand it then your expectations will be in the ballpark.

I don’t submit frequently mainly because of the cost factor. I don’t really sell too many books. Whether you agree or not with CGC grading, as a seller it is still important to be familiar with it.

If you make more without the grading then you don’t need CGC. However I personally would rather purchase from someone whose grading is on par with a reputable grading company.

So if you knock down the grades at least 3 spots, what did they really lose?

Not registering a book is a dealbreaker? Really, is that what we worry about these days. I'm lucky enough I have money to buy quality books at all with my upcoming family vacation.

As collectors we really lose our stack over silly things. I've done it. In hindsight I wish I hadn't. There are other things I could mention like asking for a refund after 2 months, but isn't the possession of a book that you've been wanting the most important thing?

If you think this wasn't there before, then it could only have happened during grading, or in shipping prior to grading.

In my opinion, grader's couldn't do that kind of damage. It honestly looks to me that somebody missed it in prior grading, or your recollection of the book is different than what you thought.

In any case, all those bends seem to be easily pressed out. There is nothing breaking colour so your book can be restored to a pretty good grade.

Try not to fret. It's good that you pressed the others.

Amazing Spider-man 138 NM  $42.00
Amazing Spider-man 139 NM 1st appearance Grizzly $48.00

Odd ASM cover perhaps but 138 was actually a decent story. It's hard to compare anything to 1-100 of that series.

22 minutes ago, TwoPiece said:

I'm assuming by "LS" you mean the 1986 5-issue series?

Yes, Although it was advertised as 1-4. I don't know the story behind that.

Punisher LS Reread it many times. Loved Zeck's art.

I sent to Ireland. Turned out ok.

I've sent another non-comic collectible elsewhere as well; France.

How do you even trust the grade when they get it that wrong?

They are a member here. I don't know how often he frequents the boards anymore. I've bought from him. I am always happy with the books. They have their own site as well as eBay. Solid dealer.

You would have thought eBay could have told you that though.

I can't imagine a dealer paying close to market value for a key, even in a package deal, or what would be the point trying to make a profit off of it.

I'm not sure they are willing to share business models anyway but I'm watching this thread just in case 

2 minutes ago, goldust40 said:

If you're not motivated enough to place a snipe, you'll forget. Done that enough times...

other than eBay, I don't know anyone who lets you snipe through third party software.

Lately, I have been wrapped up with work and family to put bids in for books I have been wanting for a long time.

I'm not getting down because I know as a collector I have to be patient but I can't seem to get the time to just sit back and plot my bid strategy.

Action Comics 1 I think. I am and always will be a Superman fan regardless of how bad they make him look in modern movies.

I have an easy question for the boards.

My 9yr old daughter is interested in reading comic books about Captain Marvel (Carol Danvers) and Gamora.

What are the best stories written about these characters that a young girl can read?

Thanks.

1 hour ago, Karl Liebl said:

They already own all the "good" comics, there is nothing left to get!

Because the art and story are done quite well

5 hours ago, Bird said:

Batman Adventures Mad Love #nn CGC 9.6 $155

If you want to be sure about the state of your books then I guess you should submit them yourself to be sure. Then it's between you, CGC, and the postman.

31 of first 100, but I have no intention of collecting some of them on the list.

Just now, october said:

SME 15

8.0

$225

Nobody cared. Movie announced. Everyone cares. 

still don't care

1 minute ago, Chazgee said:

It's an investment!

Who wants to let it go?