Syracuse, near the big mall. I went to that store a few years ago, and left the shop swearing under my breath. Had I received any service, I would've used that opening to swear much more loudly, but they were just chatting it up amongst themselves. I think the pre-faded issues were priced at exactly twice Overstreet... $12 bronze ASM? $24 sticker. Lots of stock, tons of space, but terrible prices. No surprise that the books hung on the wall unsold until they were ruined.
A boardie runs Collectibles Galore, a little north of there, which is a much better shop, and there's a fantastic fish restaurant on the way, the Clam Bar. Both are worth a visit if you're in the area.