O
This is a fascinating topic with two distinct philosophies; both have pros & cons. I can certainly understand the rationale for keeping books in a safe deposit box. As collections grow (especially in value) the appeal of increased security provided by bank storage cannot be ignored. I've actually considered safe deposit boxes over the years in spite of the fact that my collection is well monitored and insured against a variety of bad scenarios.
My gut instinct tells me that the whole idea of locking books away in a bank vault is anathema to collecting. It's like sentencing your treasured books to life behind bars in solitary confinement with conjugal visits only permissible during approved hours.
OK, maybe that's loving one's collection a leeettle too much... ...but it's a point worth exploring.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that collecting is an entirely different mind-set to investing and bank vaults seem like a real buzz-kill from a collector POV, but I'm trying to keep an open mind to both perspectives. In the high stakes game of GA comic collecting there's absolutely nothing wrong with either approach to storing rare collectibles as long as preservation is the first order of business.
Back in the 70's I briefly used a small, inexpensive Sentry fire-resistant safe, but abandoned it's use because I discovered that by design it sweated internally (even with silica packs)!
Obviously, using a safe wasn't the best option then, but that was back when GA books were plentiful, cheap and the hobby was different. Anyway, I sold the Sentry safe and went back to mylar and acid free storage boxes.
Fortunately, fire-resistant safe design has improved greatly, but in choosing this or any other alternative to the more traditional safe deposit box one must do the research and be prepared to invest a substantial amount (high quality, data grade safes aren't inexpensive, but they provide good security in addition to fire and water resistance). Of course, fully appraised insurance is highly recommended regardless of which way you go.
Given the valuable input here I'm reconsidering my dogged resistance to bank vault comic storage. I may look into moving some of my prized books to a safe deposit box simply because my collection is outgrowing the current accommodations, although the prospect of investing in another, larger data grade safe is also a viable option I've considered.
Good input all around! (thumbs u
Buzz kill or not, David, many of us have books so rare and/or important that we have a responsibility to protect them for future generations. SDBs do this better than almost any type of home security.
And those conjugal visits sure are fun!