Same here. I bid and won a few every now and then when the slabs were on ebay. Even then it appeared that CGC's grading was rather loose on many books. Now that they have moved to raw stuff I rarely find anything that looks accurately graded.
I am sure that the reason why dealers like Sparkle City Comics grade so loosely is because they are well known for buying pedigree collections,they are Overstreet advisors and so on.....so "green" collectors associate dealers like Sparkle City as being authorities in the field .
Consequently, Sparkle City know they can get away with ridiculously liberal grading standards.
There are a couple other big name dealers / Overstreet advisors who pull the same sort of tricks, with selling overgraded raw comics on eBay......green collectors will pay higher prices from these sorts of dealers because green collectors are duped into paying a premium for the dealer's status in the hobby and being able to say" I bought this from Sparkle City Comics"
This Avengers 196 looks like an 8.0 to an 8.5, just by eyeballing the pics.
2 transverse spine tics
Oxidation staining on BC
Wear on BC along upper left edge
Not only do they know how to grade, they also know how to accurately describe a book's edition.. Such as the examples below:
Dazzler #1 Newsstand #1
Dazzler #1 Newsstand #2
Maybe these are the only 2 known newsstand copies in existence?
Hmmmm… if called on their BS, I imagine that they will defend the listing description by saying that "Newsstand Fresh" is mean to convey that it is brand new, not that it's an edition that doesn't exist.
As we all know - Newsstand and fresh should never exist in one sentence