NYCC's Artist Alley is really top notch. I've gone to SDCC for the last three years, so NYCC usually isn't worth it. I only go to NYCC because my little cousin wants to go. Their Artist Alley definitely makes it worth it for me.
The only thing I will say is EoW is about as good as it gets...so I think a raw RRP has the potential to be worth $400+ but like I said I think the real key is whether u are buying as an investment or as a collector. If u are a collector I think u could rationalize paying high because u will never sell. As the Ranger develops this comic is only going to increase in value. I say buy it if u believe the condition stated is legitimate and u have the cash. 5 years from now $300 is going to seem like a steal. I turned down a Walking Dead #1 CGC 9.8 because $850 seemed too high...ugggggh!
I definitely see your point, and I'm definitely not going to close the door entirely on this particular one. However, I'm definitely little hesitant, if for no other reason than that there's another raw that ends tomorrow that's at $102 right now (which will obviously go up), there's the potential to use that finished auction as a negotiating chip, and there's a 9.6 RRP with a 9.8 first print for $400.
As for why I'm buying it, I definitely want one for my collection, but I also wouldn't mind getting a second one for down the road.
Sent u a PM