Comicdey

I figured that and think it’s overall near the mid or high side since the book is also quite nice. Thx

There we go, around where I think it’ll land but ya never know

You got hosed as a 3.5. It should be 4.5 but it’s possible they hit you additionally hard for the water spots

I think it could get a CGC 3.0 tops

You guys are killing me. Staple isn’t detached. It’s still solid to back cover. Treat it like a 1/4 inch tear in a bad location? 🤔

I’m so in on this with you

Sadly I think because the tear and missing pieces are into the art it would Cgc 0.5. But it would probably sell for a good price

Since I asked for grade opinions solid copy. Dust shadow on back. Top staple is still solidly attached to back cover but pulled through cleanly on front. grades please ?

A few weeks ago traveling. 96 books slated for the dollar bins....😱 except the three on the right those were $40 or so.

And this is on point. If I didn’t find one a decade ago I’d be all over this. But I’ll say it’s not one you have a chance to buy very often and it’s so iconic that it could easily multiply in price quickly.

Picked this up in a group of books for $1 ea. 🤗 not high grade but complete first captain atom

Or remove the cover

Just cut off the trim

Unpopular GA statements ... love it i think Supersnipe is more entertaining than 98% of all golden age comics and he used to sell like hot cakes but now only a few realize how cool they are, aside from the couple Hitler Nazi covers they sell for pennies compared to other GA.

michigan

You should just clean up this sweet thread. :-)

I’d have to sell you cool stuff to justify buying stuff. Sending the boy to college this year

So many I’d like

Still a nice copy 👍

Yes. Too much spine damage but fade is the real killer in grade

5.0 would be max but I think Cgc would say 4.5 unless you have it pressed 👍

Was thinking 5.0 but probably need to hit it harder for pobc missing.

3.5

Once priced and sold and paid for ...it ships. Whether I made a mistake or not and have to not make as much profit or loss or not. I for one do not want to deal with someone that will pull shenanigans over a couple hundred dollars. Be smart when you price. Accept what you will and be done with it. Just like I would like this person on the list so I don’t deal with issues like this. So nuff said