• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Randall Dowling

Member
  • Posts

    8,770
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Randall Dowling

  1. Group Lot:

    Thor 337, NM+ 9.4-9.6.  Stunning copy with serious upgrade potential.  First Beta Ray Bill.  My scanner doesn't do this book justice.  Newsstand Copy!

    Thor 338, NM+ 9.4-9.6  Another very high grade book.  Second Beta Ray Bill.

    Thor 339, 340, 341, 342, 360, Avg. 9.2-9.6 (339 is 9.4-9.6 and a newsstand copy).  First Stormbreaker and more.

    Total for all books- $400  Sold to JDS321

     

    Spoiler

    Comics_149.thumb.jpg.ad340cb666647349294ee3f3bc2d9c45.jpg

     

     

    Spoiler

    Comics_150.thumb.jpg.35ed51195e9bf97bfd5bac7c8a4dd176.jpg

     

    Spoiler

    Comics_151.thumb.jpg.20296ac74f2c83a9eb15fbbbcdf8ce30.jpg

     

     

    Spoiler

    Comics_152.thumb.jpg.f0bc253c3e82a9eb9423643beb7ffbe4.jpg

     

    Spoiler

    IMG_7034.thumb.JPG.29ca534fd0e12df53b48ccda1d1c2847.JPG

     

     

  2. @Axe Elf I don't think you're picking up what some of us are putting down.  Identifying a copy of Eerie 1 is so questionable that even some of the most experienced dealers that were actually buying and selling comics shortly after the book came out, won't say with confidence that a copy is genuine.  

    Yes, there are the well-documented hallmarks between the "first printing" and another printing that was apparently made from the original source material.  But in this day and age, the quality of the original was so poor that it could be (conceivably) reproduced on some old used equipment.  Like certain photocopiers.  And if all you were looking for was the blackened in portion of the guy's head and the lines in the roof of the house, etc. most of us think you're setting yourself up for getting scammed.  There are a lot of copies out there, claiming to be genuine but the majority of them are not.

    There are a couple copies that some board members have shown that have a complete provenance and as such, are almost certainly genuine.  But buying a copy in the wild, is asking to be taken advantage of.  As stated in the threads I linked for you, most experienced collectors would have difficulty feeling good buying a copy in person let alone via mail order.  Unless you have substantial access to both a verified original and some of the many knock-offs (and to date, only a couple board members have), it's nearly impossible to state authenticity definitively.  

    As I and several others have stated, I will not pursue a copy as the only thing I feel comfortable identifying is the "second printings" or counterfeits.  Particularly the bad ones.  Having said that, feel free to roll the dice.  The rest of us are just trying to help you out.  :foryou: