• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

lighthouse

Member
  • Posts

    6,192
  • Joined

Posts posted by lighthouse

  1. Obviously I have a vested interest here. :p

    But the 3 is absolutely scarcer in grade. One 9.8 never sold publicly. One 9.6 OWW sold twice in 2012 and 2014. This is just the third 9.4. None ever sold publicly. Five public sales of 9.2s (out of 11 on the census) from 2012-2015, none with white pages.

    So there’s never been a white page #3 above 9.0 offered for sale. And hasn’t been a copy between 9.2-9.6 of any page quality offered publicly since 2015.

    I don’t need to market the book. Heritage is doing just fine and that’s why I gave them these books. But the #3 is the one book I most strongly considered holding back because it’s the least likely to appear again.

  2. On 3/30/2022 at 10:14 AM, SOLAR BOY said:

    I have a couple cool coverless copies in the collection as well.  The OO bought these as a kid and read them on his bike his son told me.  He took the covers off and hung them on the wall like a poster.  Now i have to figure out what they are.  This one has an add for Batman #4 and All Star comics #4.  Any thought on what this could be?  Thank you all in advance. 

    IMG-4658.jpg

    IMG-4661.jpg

    IMG-4660.jpg

    IMG-4659.jpg

    IMG-4662.jpg

    IMG-4665.jpg

    IMG-4664.jpg

    IMG-4663.jpg

    IMG-4666.jpg

    IMG-4668.jpg

    IMG-4667.jpg

    Someone else could confirm, but I’m fairly certain that’s Action 34.

  3. We’ve done a little over $30k in consignment sales through them over the last 5 years or so. Some years not so many. Some years over $10k (this year will likely be $30k or so on its own by the time it’s done).

    I find them to be a particular good outlet for “leftover” slabs. We might send five copies of a book like NM98 or Hulk340 or Batman423 through Sarasota, get back a variety of grades, and decide to keep two of them for local sale and send the other three to MyComicShop. I don’t have to wait for the fifth customer to be interested in buying a slabbed Bat 423, and I can keep my local wall display constantly rotating.

    We aren’t a mail order store (I ship less than five packages a month and half of those are to CGC). I’m happy to give MyComicShop their cut knowing I don’t have to deal with that end of the business.

    Like many others I was disappointed in the grades I got when trying to consign raw books. Had some hot new releases I never even put on the rack rejected as 9.4s (given grades at 8.0 and 8.5) that I then sent to CGC as a test of my sanity and got 9.4 and 9.6 on. I suspect if I sent them 2.0-5.0 gold or silver we wouldn’t differ that much. But I’m unlikely to consign any raw 9.4+ recent moderns again, because the haircut of them getting sub-9 is too high. And that’s fine. My experience with everything else has been top notch.

     

  4. On 3/26/2022 at 11:08 AM, supapimp said:

    @lighthouseCan I get dibs on the showcase 55

    As you can see in the pic there are three of them. I don’t recall the condition but I believe they are nice. I remember one has a GreggyNutsackCrease on the front cover. And one is definitely cut higher than the other two.

    But it will be a while before I get to those.

    Shoot me a PM and I’ll add it to the request list and circle back when the time comes.98B5652F-2BAA-4DD0-BD8E-4B1A30BD0BE4.jpeg.6966a91e28414bd22ceec4acb82ecfd9.jpeg

  5. On 3/26/2022 at 9:24 AM, ThothAmon said:

    The books are amazing. It’s perplexing to me that CGC doesn’t change its arbitrary criteria so that a collection like this doesn’t qualify as a pedigree. 

    It is what it is. I reached out multiple times from December to February and received no follow up response.

    But fwiw I don’t think there’s quite enough breadth in the HG OO SA portion of the collection to warrant it (and the Golden Age is all secondhand). By their previously stated definitions there aren’t enough 9.4+ SA books to meet the threshold. I would expect between 80-150 to meet that particular bar (though it could be as many as 200). There will be a lot of 9.2 White in the collection, and while that’s newsworthy on FF1 (or even FF5) it really isn’t on most Silver. And some are just really nice looking 8.0-9.0 

    The books are beautiful. Gorgeous color. White pages. And they’re a wonderful time capsule having been left alone for over 5 decades (heck the Church Action 1 was only 39 years old when that collection changed hands). But the pedigree question is above my pay grade.

  6. On 3/26/2022 at 7:34 AM, Sal said:

    BenSoloMORE.gif

     

    HGOOSADC FTW

     

    Seriously want a list of books with prices lol.  Try to stay calm, Sal, i know you can do it

    From a managing expectations standpoint, it’s going to be quite a while. As previously stated I was already working 70-80 hours a week before these books arrived, and there’s no fast way to go through never-bagged-and-might-be-9.6 comics that are 55-61 years old. (Only two have come back from CGC at 9.6 so far but I doubt those will be the last two, especially since only 20 Silver Age have been slabbed so far.)

    But they will come. :)

  7. On 3/25/2022 at 3:19 PM, Neurosis138 said:

    Aha, Omega Frog Comics.  I'm very familiar with that store.  I travel to Reno/Sparks for work and have been in the store a few times.

    Introduce yourself the next time you’re in. I’ve had four boardies in that I specifically know of. Still trying to get @greggyto make the trip down. These books aren’t kept at the store but eventually a few hundred of them will hit the boxes, and some will hit the wall.

  8. On 3/18/2022 at 7:53 PM, drdonaldblake1 said:

    @lighthouse

    Is this the best collection that's come into your store and if so, what would be the second best?

    We buy about fifty collections each month. Most are small modern collections but we see a collection of 100+ Silver at a time probably fifteen times a year. 

    Second best at this store was probably a collection of 20,000 books that included 500 high grade silver and 3000 high grade bronze. 

  9. On 3/18/2022 at 6:17 AM, ThothAmon said:

    Awesome books! Collections like this will certainly help keep the craziness going. Truth is my dream is to find them not buy them. 

    It was a very sleepless night the day the first few samples were brought in for me to look at. You never expect to be suddenly handed top-10 census books that have never been inside a bag and board much less a mylar.