Four books in today:
Superman #5 2.5 S(A) -- If I had gotten it Friday this would be in Matt's hands! Small amount of glue and spine split sealed to cover!
Mystic Comics #2 2.0 -- Harley traded this to me two years ago at San Diego as a 4.0-4.5 (and it sorta looked close enough, maybe a 3.5). Don't know what to think about this one. It may change my shopping habits though. I lost $500 on this one alone.
National Comics #7 4.0 -- Metro was bang on grading this even with the bottom staple blown. My surprise of the box.
The Mask #2 5.0 -- I can't remember but I think I got this from SilverAge at San Diego three years ago...? Condition and guide don't usually matter on books like this though.
As always with my submissions: One surprise, One disappointment, and the rest in agreement.