• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

scburdet

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    5,427

  • Joined

 Content Type 

Everything posted by scburdet

  1. scburdet
    One book at a time. See pinned thread for PGM guidelines
  2. scburdet
    9.2ish
  3. scburdet
    5.0/5.5. I see no reason to disagree with a higher 5.5 pick.
  4. scburdet
    echo the issue of photo quality. 7.0 feels right to me too.
  5. scburdet
    absolute ceiling is a 3.0 probably. More like a 2.0/2.5. I think the latter
  6. scburdet
    definitely press this, but I'm not convinced it comes out. Around 7.0 now
  7. scburdet
    If you believe CGC follows its own guide, this is a 4.0. Lower limit for subscription crease is 4.5. Foxing is 4.0. The other tiny defects wouldn't be penalized further.
  8. scburdet
    please see pinned thread for PGM posting guidelines
  9. scburdet
    Max according to CGC's guide is 7.0. I assume this is a very mild subscription crease
  10. scburdet
    5.5, I'd go higher except for the splotchiness on the back
  11. scburdet
    8.0/8.5
  12. scburdet
    8.0/8.5 a little concerned about that mark by the Wolfman's knee
  13. scburdet
    3.5
  14. scburdet
    Going out on a limb here 6.5/7.0. I think this could just pull a 7.0 if pressed and the sub crease becomes less noticeable. I can't see it on the front and 7.0 is the upper limit by the book
  15. scburdet
    4.5/5.0, I'm leaning lower, but it is a 181 so probably goes against my gut
  16. scburdet
    7.0/7.5
  17. scburdet
    5.0/5.5, probably the higher. Concur with the split being the limiting factor
  18. scburdet
    7.0 here too
  19. scburdet
    3.0/3.5. I was closer to 4.0 until the split showed up
  20. scburdet
    2.5/3.0. One of those cases that looks like it will come back higher than I expect.
  21. scburdet
    tell-tale sign of color touch. I ended up getting a couple unexpected purples b/c there was no bleed through. This looks no worse than one I knowingly had graded, the label says slight C-1. 5.0 is what it looks like
  22. scburdet
    8.0/8.5
  23. scburdet
    7.0/7.5
  24. scburdet
    2.5/3.0. Lean lower
  25. scburdet
    6.0/6.5. The only thing that might rescue it is being on the reverse, but I can show you books I have with smaller, less noticeable stains on the back at 8.0 & 7.5. They are unforgiving of stains. Does this one reach the inner pages?