Game: BRONZE AGE SURVIVOR SERIES - Round 4

[Shadow]

Man-Bat (Detective #400) & Deathlok (AT #25) have left the list. The best vote turnout yet for the BA Series with 103 votes. Keep 'em coming! We are now down to 34 choices. JC had some prior commitments tonight so I'll get this Round going. Hopefully I'm right in taking this until Sunday night at 8:00 pm.

 

As usual, choose the next to depart. The top 2 vote getters are gone.

[thirdgreenham]

Marvel Team Up....it's time for you to leave, thanks for playing.

 

Andy

[DrWatson]

Swamp Thing 1. We still have his first appearance, so let's not double dip.

[Shadow]

I feel like a broken record and would love to go after another choice but I'm sticking with Marvel Team-Up #1. I think every book on this list has more "significant" BA historical aspects than this one does. While it may be a fun read, it's a DC rehash of Brave & The Bold. There is nothing new here. Spidey & the Human Torch together? I believe Strange Tales did that in the SA. I think it's survived this long due to some Spidey Man-Love.

 

Heck, the "alternate" timeline of X-Men #141 is more significant than a Spidey team-up.

[Shadow]

GS X-Men #1 has a vote?!? God loves, votes kill.

[seank]

I feel like a broken record and would love to go after another choice but I'm sticking with Marvel Team-Up #1. I think every book on this list has more "significant" BA historical aspects than this one does. While it may be a fun read, it's a DC rehash of Brave & The Bold. There is nothing new here. Spidey & the Human Torch together? I believe Strange Tales did that in the SA. I think it's survived this long due to some Spidey Man-Love.

 

Heck, the "alternate" timeline of X-Men #141 is more significant than a Spidey team-up.

 

I couldn't have said it better myself. See ya MTU.

[DrWatson]

GS X-Men #1 has a vote?!? God loves, votes kill.

 

Who? What? Where?

[MK Ultra]

I changed my vote from Supes to TOD 10. Modern importance, yeah, but Bronze, no.

[JohnT]

Still too many to choose from. Still voted for the Superman vs. Spider-man gimmick.

 

I'm surprised Ironfist 14 isn't getting some votes. Talk about minor...

[silverage12c]

Time for TOD #10 to go bye-bye.

[Jungle_Junkie]

Swamp Thing 1 - your time is up !!

 

House of Secrets 92 is the ultimate Bronze age swampy book.

[Drummy]

Iron Fist #14 got my vote. Sabretooth? Please.

 

Dan

[JLA_ALL_THE_WAY]

I'll predict right now:

 

Swampy #1 & MTU #1 exit stage right!

 

Yea, I know...really going out on a limb.

 

Rick

[arexcrooke]

GS X-Men #1 has a vote?!? God loves, votes kill.

 

Who? What? Where?

Yeah, whats up with that?

And to a much lesser extent, GL 85 is getting votes?

[Monstro]

i'm going with Detective Comics 395 (First O'Neill/Adams).

seems like a bit of a stretch to call this a BA key.

 

 

[Monstro]

who is voting for Superman 233 already? 5 votes but no one fessing up.

[Sal]

i'm voting for WbN 32 and Moon Knight until some of you other knuckleheads realise how truly lame this book is.

 

if the contest was for the worst art inside the covers, WbN would already be gone by now. have you people actually tried to read this book?

 

[Shadow]

i'm voting for WbN 32 and Moon Knight until some of you other knuckleheads realise how truly lame this book is.

 

if the contest was for the worst art inside the covers, WbN would already be gone by now. have you people actually tried to read this book?

 

 

Boy, I have to agree. I bought the Werewolf Marvel Essentials and was struck with how bad the art was in most of the books. Especially the Moon Knight one. I still think a good portion of the Moon Knight popularity is based on how cool he looks on covers, etc. The storylines rarely deliver.

 

That being said, MTU #1 still leaves before B-list Moon Knight.

[Scheradon]

I have voted for Jimmy Olsen 135 (First Darkseid) every round. This book has absolutely no importance to me. It's not completely Darkseid's fault either....I just can't get excited over a comic named after a non-hero supporting character.

[Shadow]

I'll predict right now:

 

Swampy #1 & MTU #1 exit stage right!

 

Yea, I know...really going out on a limb.

 

Rick

 

As Lee Corso would say, concerning Swamp Thing #1, "not so fast, my friend."