PGM Iron Man 1

[Timmay]

8.0 due to the lrfc

 

very nice looking copy btw

[cannonfodder]

Thanks for the input everyone. It's appreciated. (thumbs u

 

Can someone explain to me how everyone is giving this book 8.5s, even though it has about half a dozen colour-breaking spine stress lines PLUS a colour-breaking crease in the BRFC?

 

It IS a beautiful copy, with exceptionally clean edges and crisp corners. But don't those stress lines and the crease automatically pull it down to a Fine or F/VF at the most?

 

Why shouldn't it get an 8.5 when my Iron Fist 14 (with visible spine stress) pulled in a 9.6?

 

 

[drewincanada]

Yowza!!

 

How eez ziz possible?!

 

You've got horseshoes up your hiney! Congrats! (thumbs u

[Timmay]

b/c the lrfc hasn't been bent over and creased??

[TheShadowKnows]

8.0 bottom right non color breaking crease?

[TheShadowKnows]

b/c the lrfc hasn't been bent over and creased??

Hows things Timmay?Still afloat here.

[Timmay]

 

 

[TFL-migration]

I guess I see this book differently than most on here. The spine is showing some minor issues. The crease going through the black debris, BRC. Plus I see what looks like some sort of scuff mark on the BLC area. Id say it presents very well. But Id say a 8.0 maybe a outside shot of 8.5

[The Vengeance-migration]

8.5-9.0 but i lean closer to 9.0. That's an amazing book you have there buddy.

[cannonfodder]

It's back and looks like a few of you were dead on. I as hoping for an 8.5, but no dice. Also, I thought it would get OW not Cream/OW, but oh well.

 

[CAMERANIAC]

Still a nice looking copy!

[TheAvenger80]

Still beautiful and I'm STILL jealous!

[TheAvenger80]

Thanks for the input everyone. It's appreciated. (thumbs u

 

Can someone explain to me how everyone is giving this book 8.5s, even though it has about half a dozen colour-breaking spine stress lines PLUS a colour-breaking crease in the BRFC?

 

It IS a beautiful copy, with exceptionally clean edges and crisp corners. But don't those stress lines and the crease automatically pull it down to a Fine or F/VF at the most?

 

Why shouldn't it get an 8.5 when my Iron Fist 14 (with visible spine stress) pulled in a 9.6?

 

 

 

It's just not nearly as sharp as that awesome Iron Fist 14, 1st Sabretooth

[cannonfodder]

It's just not nearly as sharp as that awesome Iron Fist 14, 1st Sabretooth

 

No, it's not. And would you believe that Iron Fist 14 was a 9.2 ebay purchase?

[silverage12c]

Congrats on the IM --- I think the 8.0 was a fair grade. The wear around the top staple would have been one of the main defects, I think.

[Timmay]

Still a nice looking copy!

 

Very Nice (thumbs u (thumbs u

 

Time to throw it up on ebay for some stupid $$