2007/2008 GRADING CONTEST: Round 3

[TheWatcher]

It's no the book, it's the CGC grading

[Fan4Fan]

It's no the book, it's the CGC grading

 

But CGC grading is very consistent!

 

[djpinkpanther67]

It's no the book, it's the CGC grading

 

But CGC grading is very consistent!

 

[Sal]

 

i was going to say 9.0, then double bumped it, once for the ped and once for my natural inclination to undergrade.

 

looks like i should have stayed with the single bump. oh well, i will take the points (thumbs u

[Lazyboy]

I was on the fence between 9.0 and 9.2, went with 9.0. If I had known it was a Curator, would have gone with 9.2!

 

From an exchange between r1970d and nik on the first page, half an hour after the scans were posted:

 

"Nik, a few simple questions.

 

1) Who did you buy the book from? From a seller

2) How much did you pay? Not alot

3) Why? Its a Curator"

 

[trmoore54]

WOW...I didn't even make a triple-bogey on that one...put an "other" on my score card...

[silverage12c]

I went with a 9.0, and will gladly take the 3 points.

 

Actually, I have scored a 3-pointer on every round so far --- not too shabby, but I'll have to nail a few rounds to even have a chance!

[Professor66]

[BlowUpTheMoon]

9.2? Good lord.

 

Multiple spine stresses, impacts to the top edge and a rough top right corner.

 

Even with the Nik bump I gave it a 8.5.

 

My reasoning too for the 8.5 I gave it

[the_Greatest]

9.2? Good lord.

 

Multiple spine stresses, impacts to the top edge and a rough top right corner.

 

Even with the Nik bump I gave it a 8.5.

 

My reasoning too for the 8.5 I gave it

 

My reasoning too for the 8.5 I gave it

[Dick Pontoon]

9.2? Good lord.

 

Multiple spine stresses, impacts to the top edge and a rough top right corner.

 

Even with the Nik bump I gave it a 8.5.

 

My reasoning too for the 8.5 I gave it

 

My reasoning too for the 8.5 I gave it

 

Same here, except Mr. Simplesoul went even lower. I don't think I've ever been as far off as this. Here comes the negative points!

[Pirate]

I need to go back to nik bumping, it's what won it for me last year. I have been one grade off so far each round

[Ze-man]

9.2? Good lord.

 

Multiple spine stresses, impacts to the top edge and a rough top right corner.

 

Even with the Nik bump I gave it a 8.5.

 

My reasoning too for the 8.5 I gave it

 

My reasoning too for the 8.5 I gave it

 

Count me among the 8.5 losers!

 

And to think I thought me guessing 8.5 WAS adding in a Nik bump.

 

Funny stuff.

 

Congrats to those who nailed it.

 

Ze-

 

 

[nik]

Bout time I get DC bumps

[greggy]

Bout time I get DC bumps

9.2

[eddly]

9.2? Good lord.

 

Multiple spine stresses, impacts to the top edge and a rough top right corner.

 

Even with the Nik bump I gave it a 8.5.

I gave it an 8.0.

 

Me too. I guess I am picky.

[Ze-man]

Bout time I get DC bumps

 

Are those a side effect from your injury? I thought people called those scars.

 

[THE_BEYONDER]

9.2? Good lord.

 

Multiple spine stresses, impacts to the top edge and a rough top right corner.

 

Even with the Nik bump I gave it a 8.5.

I gave it an 8.0.

 

Me too

[greggy]

9.2? Good lord.

 

Multiple spine stresses, impacts to the top edge and a rough top right corner.

 

Even with the Nik bump I gave it a 8.5.

I gave it an 8.0.

 

Me too

[sckao]

 

I gave it an 8.5