Opinions - with Results now!

[Scheradon]

I got my three submissions back from CGC and wanted to garner some of your guesses on the grades.

 

Tarzan #25 (the line going through the palm leaf is not on the book)

 

Marvel Spotlight V2 #1

 

Shogun Warriors #19

[silverage12c]

Tarzan 9.6

Spotlight 9.2

Shogun Warriors 9.6

[Transplant]

9.6

9.2

9.6

In that order.

 

[joeypost]

9.4

9.2

9.6

[Scheradon]

BTW: I'll post the grades tomorrow evening at around 7pm central. Thanks for your guys imput!

[Point Five]

Tarzan 9.6

Spotlight 9.2

Shogun Warriors 9.6

These were my guesses too, even before seeing your post & Transplants.

 

Hard to finetune the grades at this HG level with scans a bit on the small side. But clearly nice books! (thumbs u

[Comicdey]

just to be different

 

9.6

 

9.2

 

9.8........not that I can really tell from the scan.

[CAP Freak]

9.4

9.2

9.6

[topofthetotem]

9.8

9.4

9.6

[rob_allan]

9.6

9.4

9.8

 

Honestly kinda hard to tell all that much from the scans, but probably somewhere around there for all of them.

 

-Rob-

[Scheradon]

9.6

9.4

9.8

 

Honestly kinda hard to tell all that much from the scans, but probably somewhere around there for all of them.

 

-Rob-

 

Trust me, just about as hard to tell having them in hand.

[Pitboss]

9.6

9.6

9.8

[CAMERANIAC]

9.4

9.2

9.6

[trmoore54]

9.6...could be 9.8

9.4

9.8...could be 9.6

 

Nice ones...

[THE_BEYONDER]

9.6

9.4

9.8

 

Honestly kinda hard to tell all that much from the scans, but probably somewhere around there for all of them.

 

-Rob-

 

Trust me, just about as hard to tell having them in hand.

 

2nd book has issues along the top edge of the BC. From the scans provided, I see no reason 1 & 3 wouldn't grade NM+ or higher

[Theagenes]

9.8

9.4

9.6

 

My guesses as well. Love the Tarzan 25! Those last few issues of Marvel's Tarzan run was one of my favorite story arcs as a kid.

 

Jeff

[The_Spirit]

9.8, 9.6, 9.8

[Scheradon]

Okay, now the moment of truth...

 

Tarzan #25.

Nobody (including myself) guessed the right grade. This one realy puzzles me the most and makes me think I must have missed something on the inside. Grades were: 2: 9.8, 7: 9.6, and 3: 9.4. I thought it had a good 9.8 shot, but CGC begged to differ.

 

Marvel Spotlight V2 #1.

Several people guessed right on this one. The back cover comes out a bit exaggerated in the scan. There is a bit of overhang which resulted in the slight "curve over" that's apearing. I don't remember seeing this when I had it in the bag and board. I thought 9.6 possibly when I sent it. Grades here were: 1: 9.6, 4: 9.4, and 7: 9.2.

 

Shogun Warriors #19.

Thought this was a 9.8 for sure. Grades here: 4: 9.8 and 8: 9.6.

 

 

Submitting these might have been a finacial snafu, but, by recieving these three different grades, I now have a nice "key set" for comparison on other books, as I now own a 9.2 through 10.0 in my collection in each increment.

 

Thanks again guys for your imput!

 

 

 

[joeypost]

Does closest to the pin win?

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Does closest to the pin win?

 

As long as you're on the green (thumbs u