2007/2008 GRADING CONTEST: ROUND 6

[Blackwolvie-migration]

off by 2 (8.5) I thought I went over ouch...

[JohnT]

I considered 9.2, but thought there were too many nicks and soft corners. Went with 9.0.

 

These high grade comics are killing me.

[THE_BEYONDER]

I got it right for once but I'm trolling just for the hell of it.

 

I figure VF/NM at best, and went 8.5 in case I missed something.

[Timmay]

I considered 9.2, but thought there were too many nicks and soft corners. Went with 9.0.

 

These high grade comics are killing me.

 

I thought DC comics were impervious to the Nik Bump

 

[pkw]

NO WAY!

 

I said 8.0 - this should please those of you who are waiting for lists of my comics as I am going through and regrading from my fist ignorant pass of a month ago!

 

 

[s-man]

8.5 ---- 36

 

Well at least I wasn't the only one thinking 8.5

[silverage12c]

Thought I had this one nailed at a 9.0 --- but I will gladly take the 3 pts!

[Professor66]

[JohnT]

 

[sckao]

Results coming up....

 

 

http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=2102506&page=1#Post2102506

 

 

[THE_BEYONDER]

 

[Fan4Fan]

I considered 9.2, but thought there were too many nicks and soft corners. Went with 9.0.

 

These comics graded when the graders were high are killing me.

 

There... fixed it for you!

[JohnT]

I considered 9.2, but thought there were too many nicks and soft corners. Went with 9.0.

 

These comics graded when the graders were high are killing me.

 

There... fixed it for you!

 

Thanks!

[1Cool]

9.2?? I had a Spectre! 3 that was graded 9.0 that had a bunch less spine marks. I really can't understand CGC's grading. But at least I'm not the only one that picked 8.5 and I changed it from a 8.0 to be safe. WOW!!

[blue808]

I considered 9.2, but thought there were too many nicks and soft corners. Went with 9.0.

 

These high grade comics are killing me.

 

I thought the exact same thing. Spine ticks drops this book to 9.0 for me.

[grandz-migration]

Wow....wow. I, I, don't know what to say except, if I ever sell my comics

on these boards, people are going to get some veeeery nice under graded books.

[VintageComics]

Nik, I have to ask. How did you grade this book before you sent it in.

 

R.

 

 

[Transplant]

Wow. That is a terrible looking 9.2. I called it an 8.0.

[joeypost]

I said 9.2 and have jumped in the standing to #35

[djpinkpanther67]

I thought it around a F/VF (7.5) Don't know what I was thinking in my percoset induced haze