Who would win in battle Joe Collector vs MMMarvel aka Hulk 181

[GotToHaveComics]

Sorry guys. I enjoyed your post too much that I can't resist to have this poll.

 

 

 

[supapimp]

what happened to "who cares, i'd rather smoke crack!"? im not voting BTW.

[Rip]

What kind of battle.

fight club.... verbal damage......thunderdome......

[davidpg]

[GotToHaveComics]

My intention of the Battle is more on the speculation about Hulk 181 price. About 6 years from now (2009), during the 10th year anniversary of CGC, we maybe close to the actual number of high grade 181s. Will the value decrease based from the contention of Joe Collector that there are too many high grade 181s or the value increase because the assumption that too many high grade 181 is untrue?

 

 

 

 

[ninanina]

Hulk 181 is not an ordinary comic. No matter how many are out there, everyone wants one - eventually. The price is going up. Let's just call it a "mutant" comic. Don't think anything will ever touch it in terms of long term value.

 

But that's just me.

 

($20,000.00 comic in 19 1/2 years.)

[Kevin Boyd]

Not everyone.

 

I traded my copy of Incredible Hulk 181 for a copy of What If...? 1 when I was 10 years old in 1979 (and they were worth about the same).

 

I still like What if...? #1 more as it's a better story IMO. I haven't tried to get another Hulk 181 since then (although I do have a copy of an oversized european reprint).

 

As far as first appearances go, it's not a great one. The only reason I would consider getting one now is to complete my run of Incredible Hulk, which is not something I'm actively doing at the moment.

 

Kev

[ninanina]

Not everyone.

 

I traded my copy of Incredible Hulk 181 for a copy of What If...? 1 when I was 10 years old in 1979 (and they were worth about the same).

 

I still like What if...? #1 more as it's a better story IMO. I haven't tried to get another Hulk 181 since then (although I do have a copy of an oversized european reprint).

 

As far as first appearances go, it's not a great one. The only reason I would consider getting one now is to complete my run of Incredible Hulk, which is not something I'm actively doing at the moment.

 

Kev

 

Ok, everyone wants one except for kevthemev.

[drbanner]

This has become a slugfest folks!

 

MM jumped out to the early lead ( ), but Joe came storming back...then MM...then Joe blows 'im away with a 2-vote lead, but now MM has turned this thing around and is currently ahead!

 

How's it going to end? Or will it? The suspense is killing me!!

[greggy]

Ok, everyone wants one except for kevthemev.

 

I read it a bit ago - forget if it was on here or a link from here to the net. You can add POV to the list who don;t want. Actually, I DO at a cheap price whwere I can trade it towards my want list!

Ditto! Never was a priority for me back in the day. I was content with my copy that was only a VF!

[Illiterati-migration]

Ok, everyone wants one except for kevthemev.

 

I read it a bit ago - forget if it was on here or a link from here to the net. You can add POV to the list who don;t want. Actually, I DO at a cheap price whwere I can trade it towards my want list!

Ditto! Never was a priority for me back in the day. I was content with my copy that was only a VF!

 

I hate Wolverine. Add me to the list.

[COI]

Ok, everyone wants one except for kevthemev.

 

I read it a bit ago - forget if it was on here or a link from here to the net. You can add POV to the list who don;t want. Actually, I DO at a cheap price whwere I can trade it towards my want list!

Ditto! Never was a priority for me back in the day. I was content with my copy that was only a VF!

 

I hate Wolverine. Add me to the list.

 

And me. I don't hate Wolverine(don't really like him either), but I REALLY hate that book. I get the feeling that fanboys actually sleep with their copies once aquiring them.

[joe_collector]

And me. I don't hate Wolverine(don't really like him either), but I REALLY hate that book. I get the feeling that fanboys actually sleep with their copies once aquiring them.

 

I like the cover layout and intent, but the Trimpe art (inside and out) gives me a headache.

[Joanna]

I have no interest in that book. Never heard of it until I came here.

[GotToHaveComics]

Are you a new collector? There so many thread on the 181 in this forum for at least a year already.

[THE_BEYONDER]

Never heard of it until I came here.

 

 

I think she meant when she came to these boards.......not this thread.