PGM Amazing Spider-Man #18

[Shark]

How much would you guys knock off for the crease at the lower right corner of the front cover? Beautiful book otherwise. Worth CGC grading?

 

Mike

 

 

[rza808]

Thats tough to grade. 9.0 or 8.5? :shrug:

[THE_BEYONDER]

No way is a book with those creases getting a 9.0

[marvelcollector]

7.0...I'd say it might be a VF without the creases......

[Point Five]

Yep! 7.0 seems about right. With the crease(s) LRC, smudge ULC and a few scattered dents, I don't think it can go much higher. Still, very attractive book!

[joeypost]

Is there something going on with the top corner BC? If not (looks like an impact dent) 6.5/7.0.

[Shadow]

6.5, maybe soft 7.0. The creases and damage to the bottom FC keeps it from going any higher. Still a very presentable, nice copy.

[TFL-migration]

9.0??? No way, no how, never. I'd go a solid 6.5 Nice Book..

[silverage12c]

I think this could get a 7.0, but no higher than that.

[Shark]

Thanks for the posts guys. I personally had graded it a 7.5 (VF-) but I wasn't sure how much the creases counted as a deduction. I think I'll send it in to CGC and I'll let you know later what grade it gets from the big boys.

 

Mike

[Aces]

No way is a book with those creases getting a 9.0

Not even Nik...

6.5 (thumbs u

[burntboy]

Yep! 7.0 seems about right. With the crease(s) LRC, smudge ULC and a few scattered dents, I don't think it can go much higher. Still, very attractive book!

 

What he said - 7.0ish.............

[Primetime]

6.5 tops...CGC will say 6.0...leave raw...

[rza808]

I have seen 2 9.0's with a crease in that spot just not as hard on the eyes. Although 1 was much smaller and the other book;'s crease was a lighter tone of cover color. Granted on second look the book has 2 or 3 creases in that corner and smudge on upper left corner. wasnt really doing a good job grading trying to be quick. But I forgot how serious people werein the pgm section. Dont want people overgrading potential purchases do we?

[CAP Freak]

7.5

[djpinkpanther67]

F/VF maybe VF-

[piper]

7.0

[fishbone]

6.5 tops...CGC will say 6.0...leave raw...

 

Absolutely!! The only way to go...waste of time and $$ otherwise

[clay allen-migration]

HMMMM… Spine corners show some abrasion; 2 creases with abrasion in LRC; A tear or crease on the R edge (in the black area); soiling near upper staple?; soiling ULC; abrasion ULC; abrasion with color loss along top & bottom edges. No info on pages, but the bottom looks like there may be slight fanning.

Grade = FN+

 

[homerwannabee]

6.5 tops...CGC will say 6.0...leave raw...

 

Absolutely!! The only way to go...waste of time and $$ otherwise

 

 

I disagree. A 6.0 ASM would probably bring in over $100.