a Superman #1 in a different CGC holder on ebay?

[justin]

OK, I've never seen THIS before. I know of PGX and ACE but this looks entirely custom and pretty poorly made. Granted he doesn't try to pass it off as a CGC book but then what is it? At least he graded it right

[seank]

It looks like he put the book into a CGC outer holder to better display the book.

[towards2112]

Also a member here, in Gold and forum selling section if memory serves.

[justin]

He wrote this after the pictures. Maybe he can explain it here.

 

"I’ve been collecting comics since 1968. I am a regular participant on the CGC message boards (member name: tabcom)."

[Ogami]

I wouldn't call it a "fake" holder so much as a homemade holder, especially since he doesn't even reference it, let alone hard sell it. Also, he's a boardie, so decorum might dictate less inflamatory terms.

 

 

[JazzMan]

Also a member here, in Gold and forum selling section if memory serves.

 

Yup, that corner of the front cover is his avatar, if I'm not mistaken. I don't think it's meant to mislead, just to display.

[justin]

didn't know he was a boardie. I changed my title to "different" instead of "fake". I didn't mean anything inflamatory, just curious is all.

[Ogami]

didn't know he was a boardie. I changed my title to "different" instead of "fake". I didn't mean anything inflamatory, just curious is all.

 

good man. (thumbs u

[snitzer]

it's tabcom's

 

http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=2362911&fpart=1

[justin]

Since he's vouched for here, this thread can be deleted.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

[/img]