Resub Results?

[JvR11]

I was just curious if some of you out there have submitted resubs and what has been your experience? Has the grade changed?

 

 

 

[BeachBum]

Grades have remained the same or gone down 1 notch (9.2 went to a 9.0)

 

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

I saw that MK broke out a 9.6, had it signed and it came back a 9.8

[MstrTech]

My B&B 28 & 30 both graded 9.0 resubed (nothing done in between) came back 9.2's. (thumbs u

Couple of others didn't change.

[Nostalgic Attic]

I have cracked and resubbed 15 books. 10 came back higher 3 came back the same. and the other two.....still trying to figure those out, since in theory they look nicer than the assigned grade- how the heck they could grade lower...I dunno.

 

No "work" was done to any of them.

 

I have had one book pressed which went from an 8.5 to a 9.0.

[namisgr]

When I first purchased slabbed books I invariably cracked them out. As a consequence, I've resubmitted dozens of books in the last few years.

 

Some grades have gone up. In one case, by alot (from 9.0 to 9.4). Some grades have gone down. In one case, by alot (from 9.2 to 8.5). I had a book purchased as a blue label 9.0 come back (after spending a few years without manipulation in a mylar with fullback) as a green label 9.0, with "staples cleaned". Some books received the same numerical grade but changed their page quality designation. I've also had plenty of books receive the same grade.

[bghkoyama]

I've only cracked and re-subbed one comic. A CGC 9.6 White pages New Mutants #98 was re-subbed and came back a CGC 9.8 White pages.

That's the only comic I really thought had a shot at 9.8 when I first subbed it.

 

Brian

[BeachBum]

I saw that MK broke out a 9.6, had it signed and it came back a 9.8

 

Yeah that was my X-Men 117 ... that came back to me...

 

My own little test a few months back didn't have quite the same results.

[devilsrain]

I saw that MK broke out a 9.6, had it signed and it came back a 9.8

 

Yeah that was my X-Men 117 ... that came back to me...

 

My own little test a few months back didn't have quite the same results.

 

 

Is society spelled wrong on purpose?

[bghkoyama]

I saw that MK broke out a 9.6, had it signed and it came back a 9.8

 

Yeah that was my X-Men 117 ... that came back to me...

 

My own little test a few months back didn't have quite the same results.

 

Don't forget the Hulk #181 that was busted out of it's 9.6 case, signed, and came back 9.8....

[akaSteveRogers]

I had a bad yr last year with cracking slabs for signatures.

 

11 books submitted for signatures. 5 dropped in grade. (1) 9.8 to 9.2 damaged in transit, (1) 9.8 to 9.6, (2) 9.6 to 9.2 damaged in transit, and (1) 9.4 to 9.2.

 

All the rest stayed the same.

 

 

 

 

 

 

[toro]

Only resubbed one book, it went from 9.2 to 9.0!

[bghkoyama]

I had a bad yr last year with cracking slabs for signatures.

 

11 books submitted for signatures. 5 dropped in grade. (1) 9.8 to 9.2 damaged in transit, (1) 9.8 to 9.6, (2) 9.6 to 9.2 damaged in transit, and (1) 9.4 to 9.2.

 

All the rest stayed the same.

 

 

Ouch! Damaged in transit meaning the witness damaged it while either cracking it out or taking it to get signed? Or damaged going to CGC?

[BeachBum]

I saw that MK broke out a 9.6, had it signed and it came back a 9.8

 

Yeah that was my X-Men 117 ... that came back to me...

 

My own little test a few months back didn't have quite the same results.

 

 

Is society spelled wrong on purpose?

 

LOL

 

You're the first person who noticed that!!! You get a cookie!

 

 

I was waiting for someone to say something... I made it so obvious... It was my little Ron Burgundy moment.

[EvilAsh]

I saw that MK broke out a 9.6, had it signed and it came back a 9.8

 

I've personally had this happen to me twice,

and I've also had 2 9.4's go up to 9.6's after being signed

[Genesis Comics]

I had a book signed by Frazetta that went from a 9.4 to a 9.6

[akaSteveRogers]

I had a bad yr last year with cracking slabs for signatures.

 

11 books submitted for signatures. 5 dropped in grade. (1) 9.8 to 9.2 damaged in transit, (1) 9.8 to 9.6, (2) 9.6 to 9.2 damaged in transit, and (1) 9.4 to 9.2.

 

All the rest stayed the same.

 

 

Ouch! Damaged in transit meaning the witness damaged it while either cracking it out or taking it to get signed? Or damaged going to CGC?

 

going to CGC.

[joeypost]

Are these straight re-subs?

[bghkoyama]

Mine was. Got it, didn't like the grade, popped it out, sent it in with the next batch of comics.

[taro90]

Had my first resub, it came back the same grade. It was cracked out for the CGC SS. Let's hope that stays the same. Because next week at the NYCC, I'm looking to crack out 4 books to get them signed for CGC SS.