• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Infinite Marvel Picture Frame books
23 23

Started by Guardian Comics,

4,838 posts in this topic

  • Popular Post
Ghost Town

Ghost Town

Posted
  • Popular Post
Posted (edited)

It’s back! Because nobody asked for it!

My latest deep and dangerous dive into the CGC census.

(With thanks to Greg Holland’s cgcdata.com website and Excel's sort feature.)

I think Greg Reece and sons are responsible for a lot of the changes with those awesome Westerns they uncovered. 

The last time I looked was in January of this year. Since then...
7 first time 9.8s popped up on the census.
2 first time 9.6s popped up on the census.
1 first time 9.4 popped up on the census.

For the first time, I noticed how tough some issues of Thor and Subby are to find in 9.8.

Of the 388 Picture Frame books total, there are:
103 books without a 9.8 (it was 110 as of 1/31/21)
44 books with 1 9.8+
35 books with no 9.6+ (was 37)
11 books with no 9.4+ (was 12)
6 books with no 9.2+
2 books with no 9.0+

No 9.0+
Millie the Model #197 
My Love #20 

No 9.2+
Millie the Model #194 
Millie the Model #195 
Millie the Model #197 
Millie the Model #198 
Millie the Model #199 
My Love #20

No 9.4+
Harvey #3 
Li'l Kids #7 
Li'l Kids #9 
My Love #20 
Millie the Model #194 
Millie the Model #195 
Millie the Model #196 
Millie the Model #197 
Millie the Model #198 
Millie the Model $199 
Our Love Story #20 

No 9.6+
Chili #18 
Chili #19 
Chili #20 
Harvey #3 
Harvey #4 
Harvey #5 
Harvey #6 
Li'l Kids #4 
Li'l Kids #5 
Li'l Kids #6
Li'l Kids #7 
Li'l Kids #9 
Li'l Pals #1 
Li'l Pals #2 
Mighty Marvel Western #16 
Mighty Marvel Western #17 
Millie the Model #194 
Millie the Model #195 
Millie the Model #196 
Millie the Model #197 
Millie the Model #198 
Millie the Model #199 
My Love #14 
My Love #16 
My Love #20 
Our Love Story #17 
Our Love Story #20 
Outlaw Kid #10 
Rawhide Kid #100 
Rawhide Kid 105 
Ringo Kid #14 
Special Marvel Edition #4 
Two-Gun Kid #101 
Western Gunfighters #8 
Western Kid #5 

Toughest Hero Books

No 9.8s
Iron Man #44 (9 in 9.6)
Avengers #103 (12 in 9.6)
Captain Marvel #22 (4 in 9.6)
Incredible Hulk #158 (7 in 9.6)
Marvel Feature #6 (9 in 9.6)
Marvel Premiere #5 (5 in 9.6)
X-Men #76 (7 in 9.6)

1 in 9.8
Amazing Adventures #9 (2 in 9.6)
Astonishing Tales #12 (5 in 9.6)
Astonishing Tales #14 (9 in 9.6)
Daredevil #93 (7 in 9.6)
Daredevil Annual #3 (7 in 9.6)
Incredible Hulk #145 (20 in 9.6)
Incredible Hulk Annual #4 (3 in 9.6)

2 in 9.8
Avengers #93 
Avengers #105 
Captain Marvel #23 
Daredevil #86 
Defenders #2 
Sub-Mariner #43
Sub-Mariner #46 
Sub-Mariner #53 
Thor #197 
Thor #198 
Thor #201 
Thor #205 
Warlock #3 

3 in 9.8
Astonishing Tales #9 
Captain America #155 
Fantastic Four #117 
Fantastic Four #120 
Incredible Hulk #151
Iron Man #52 
Marvel Feature #3 
Marvel Team-Up #1 
Sub-Mariner #45 
Sub-Mariner Annual #2 
Thor #206 

Most submissions
Marvel Spotlight #5 - 3789
Hero for Hire #1 – 2946
Tomb of Dracula #1 - 2077
Marvel Premiere #1 - 1916
Defenders #1 - 1503

Fewest submissions
Chili #18 - 2
Chili #19 - 2
Harvey #3 - 2
Harvey #6 - 2
Li'l Kids #4 - 2
Ringo Kid #14 - 2
Chili #20 - 1
Li'l Kids #6 - 1
Millie the Model #199 - 1

Toughest 25¢ books in 9.4+
Special Marvel Edition #4 - 1 in 9.4 (9 in 9.2)
Mighty Marvel Western #16 - 2 in 9.4 (4 in 9.2)
My Love #14 - 3 in 9.4 (7 in 9.2)

Monstrosities
Tomb of Dracula #1 has 54 9.8s, Werewolf by Night #1 has just 3
Chamber of Darkness Annual #1 - 0 in 9.8s (6 in 9.6)
Where Monsters Dwell #12 - 0 in 9.8 (6 in 9.6)
Creatures on the Loose #14 - 0 in 9.8 (6 in 9.6)
Where Monsters Dwell #14 - 0 in 9.8 (1 in 9.6)

Hyborian Tidbits
Conan #11 - only 1 9.8 (37 in 9.6)  
Conan #12 - 4 in 9.8 (19 in 9.6)       

Sgt. Fury can be tough
There are no 9.8 copes of #95, #97, #99, and #105 in the census

The Not OK Corral
Mighty Marvel Western #16 - 2 in 9.4 (4 in 9.2)
Two-Gun Kid #101 - No 9.6+ copies (4 in 9.4)
Western Gunfighter #8 - No 9.6+ copies 4 (1 in 9.4)
Western Kid # 5 - No 9.6+ copies (3 in 9.4)
Wyatt Earp 31 - 1 in 9.6 (5 in 9.4)
Rawhide Kid #100 - No 9.6+ copies (5 in 9.4)
Rawhide Kid #105 - No 9.6+ copies (4 in 9.4)
Ringo Kid #14 - No 9.6+ copies (1 in 9.4)
Ringo Kid #17 - 1 in 9.6 (1 in 9.4)
Outlaw Kid #10 - No 9.6+ copies (7 in 9.4)

 

Edited by Ghost Town
Link to comment
Share on other sites
WernerVonDoom

WernerVonDoom

Posted
Posted
On 10/18/2021 at 5:05 PM, Ghost Town said:

It’s back! Because nobody asked for it!

My latest deep and dangerous dive into the CGC census.

(With thanks to Greg Holland’s cgcdata.com website and Excel's sort feature.)

I think Greg Reece and sons are responsible for a lot of changes with those awesome Westerns they uncovered. 

The last time I looked was in January of this year. Since then...
7 first time 9.8s popped up on the census.
2 first time 9.6s popped up on the census.
1 first time 9.4 popped up on the census.

For the first time, I noticed how tough some issues of Thor and Subby are to find in 9.8.

Of the 388 Picture Frame books total, there are:
103 books without a 9.8 (it was 110 as of 1/31/21)
44 books with 1 9.8+
35 books with no 9.6+ (was 37)
11 books with no 9.4+ (was 12)
6 books with no 9.2+
2 books with no 9.0+

No 9.0+
Millie the Model #197 
My Love #20 

No 9.2+
Millie the Model #194 
Millie the Model #195 
Millie the Model #197 
Millie the Model #198 
Millie the Model #199 
My Love #20

No 9.4+
Harvey #3 
Li'l Kids #7 
Li'l Kids #9 
My Love #20 
Millie the Model #194 
Millie the Model #195 
Millie the Model #196 
Millie the Model #197 
Millie the Model #198 
Millie the Model $199 
Our Love Story #20 

No 9.6+
Chili #18 
Chili #19 
Chili #20 
Harvey #3 
Harvey #4 
Harvey #5 
Harvey #6 
Li'l Kids #4 
Li'l Kids #5 
Li'l Kids #6
Li'l Kids #7 
Li'l Kids #9 
Li'l Pals #1 
Li'l Pals #2 
Mighty Marvel Western #16 
Mighty Marvel Western #17 
Millie the Model #194 
Millie the Model #195 
Millie the Model #196 
Millie the Model #197 
Millie the Model #198 
Millie the Model #199 
My Love #14 
My Love #16 
My Love #20 
Our Love Story #17 
Our Love Story #20 
Outlaw Kid #10 
Rawhide Kid #100 
Rawhide Kid 105 
Ringo Kid #14 
Special Marvel Edition #4 
Two-Gun Kid #101 
Western Gunfighters #8 
Western Kid #5 

Toughest Hero Books

No 9.8s
Iron Man #44 (9 in 9.6)
Avengers #103 (12 in 9.6)
Captain Marvel #22 (4 in 9.6)
Incredible Hulk #158 (7 in 9.6)
Marvel Feature #6 (9 in 9.6)
Marvel Premiere #5 (5 in 9.6)
X-Men #76 (7 in 9.6)

1 in 9.8
Amazing Adventures #9 (2 in 9.6)
Astonishing Tales #12 (5 in 9.6)
Astonishing Tales #14 (9 in 9.6)
Daredevil #93 (7 in 9.6)
Daredevil Annual #3 (7 in 9.6)
Incredible Hulk #145 (20 in 9.6)
Incredible Hulk Annual #4 (3 in 9.6)

2 in 9.8
Avengers #93 
Avengers #105 
Captain Marvel #23 
Daredevil #86 
Defenders #2 
Sub-Mariner #43
Sub-Mariner #46 
Sub-Mariner #53 
Thor #197 
Thor #198 
Thor #201 
Thor #205 
Warlock #3 

3 in 9.8
Astonishing Tales #9 
Captain America #155 
Fantastic Four #117 
Fantastic Four #120 
Incredible Hulk #151
Iron Man #52 
Marvel Feature #3 
Marvel Team-Up #1 
Sub-Mariner #45 
Sub-Mariner Annual #2 
Thor #206 

Most submissions
Marvel Spotlight #5 - 3789
Hero for Hire #1 – 2946
Tomb of Dracula #1 - 2077
Marvel Premiere #1 - 1916
Defenders #1 - 1503

Fewest submissions
Chili #18 - 2
Chili #19 - 2
Harvey #3 - 2
Harvey #6 - 2
Li'l Kids #4 - 2
Ringo Kid #14 - 2
Chili #20 - 1
Li'l Kids #6 - 1
Millie the Model #199 - 1

Toughest 25¢ books in 9.4+
Special Marvel Edition #4 - 1 in 9.4 (9 in 9.2)
Mighty Marvel Western #16 - 2 in 9.4 (4 in 9.2)
My Love #14 - 3 in 9.4 (7 in 9.2)

Monstrosities
Tomb of Dracula #1 has 54 9.8s, Werewolf by Night #1 has just 3
Chamber of Darkness Annual #1 - 0 in 9.8s (6 in 9.6)
Where Monsters Dwell #12 - 0 in 9.8 (6 in 9.6)
Creatures on the Loose #14 - 0 in 9.8 (6 in 9.6)
Where Monsters Dwell#14 - 0 in 9.8 (1 in 9.6)

Hyborian Tidbits
Conan #11 – only 1 9.8 (37 in 9.6)  
Conan #12 – 4 in 9.8 (19 in 9.6)       

Sgt. Fury can be tough
There are no 9.8 copes of #95, #97, #99, and #105 in the census

The Not OK Corral
Mighty Marvel Western #16 - 2 in 9.4 (4 in 9.2)
Two-Gun Kid #101 No 9.6+ copies (4 in 9.4)
Western Gunfighters # 8 No 9.6+ copies 4 (1 in 9.4)
Western Kid # 5 No 9.6+ copies (3 in 9.4)
Wyatt Earp 31 1 in 9.6 (5 in 9.4)
Rawhide Kid #100 - No 9.6+ copies (5 in 9.4)
Rawhide Kid #105 - No 9.6+ copies (4 in 9.4)
Ringo Kid #14 No 9.6+ copies (1 in 9.4)
Ringo Kid #17 1 in 9.6 (1 in 9.4)
Outlaw Kid #10 No 9.6+ copies (7 in 9.4)

 

Love when you do this! Such great info - can't believe there are still two books that don't have a 9.0.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
comic_memories

comic_memories

Posted
Posted
On 10/18/2021 at 8:05 PM, Ghost Town said:

It’s back! Because nobody asked for it!

My latest deep and dangerous dive into the CGC census.

(With thanks to Greg Holland’s cgcdata.com website and Excel's sort feature.)

I think Greg Reece and sons are responsible for a lot of the changes with those awesome Westerns they uncovered. 

The last time I looked was in January of this year. Since then...
7 first time 9.8s popped up on the census.
2 first time 9.6s popped up on the census.
1 first time 9.4 popped up on the census.

For the first time, I noticed how tough some issues of Thor and Subby are to find in 9.8.

Of the 388 Picture Frame books total, there are:
103 books without a 9.8 (it was 110 as of 1/31/21)
44 books with 1 9.8+
35 books with no 9.6+ (was 37)
11 books with no 9.4+ (was 12)
6 books with no 9.2+
2 books with no 9.0+

No 9.0+
Millie the Model #197 
My Love #20 

No 9.2+
Millie the Model #194 
Millie the Model #195 
Millie the Model #197 
Millie the Model #198 
Millie the Model #199 
My Love #20

No 9.4+
Harvey #3 
Li'l Kids #7 
Li'l Kids #9 
My Love #20 
Millie the Model #194 
Millie the Model #195 
Millie the Model #196 
Millie the Model #197 
Millie the Model #198 
Millie the Model $199 
Our Love Story #20 

No 9.6+
Chili #18 
Chili #19 
Chili #20 
Harvey #3 
Harvey #4 
Harvey #5 
Harvey #6 
Li'l Kids #4 
Li'l Kids #5 
Li'l Kids #6
Li'l Kids #7 
Li'l Kids #9 
Li'l Pals #1 
Li'l Pals #2 
Mighty Marvel Western #16 
Mighty Marvel Western #17 
Millie the Model #194 
Millie the Model #195 
Millie the Model #196 
Millie the Model #197 
Millie the Model #198 
Millie the Model #199 
My Love #14 
My Love #16 
My Love #20 
Our Love Story #17 
Our Love Story #20 
Outlaw Kid #10 
Rawhide Kid #100 
Rawhide Kid 105 
Ringo Kid #14 
Special Marvel Edition #4 
Two-Gun Kid #101 
Western Gunfighters #8 
Western Kid #5 

Toughest Hero Books

No 9.8s
Iron Man #44 (9 in 9.6)
Avengers #103 (12 in 9.6)
Captain Marvel #22 (4 in 9.6)
Incredible Hulk #158 (7 in 9.6)
Marvel Feature #6 (9 in 9.6)
Marvel Premiere #5 (5 in 9.6)
X-Men #76 (7 in 9.6)

1 in 9.8
Amazing Adventures #9 (2 in 9.6)
Astonishing Tales #12 (5 in 9.6)
Astonishing Tales #14 (9 in 9.6)
Daredevil #93 (7 in 9.6)
Daredevil Annual #3 (7 in 9.6)
Incredible Hulk #145 (20 in 9.6)
Incredible Hulk Annual #4 (3 in 9.6)

2 in 9.8
Avengers #93 
Avengers #105 
Captain Marvel #23 
Daredevil #86 
Defenders #2 
Sub-Mariner #43
Sub-Mariner #46 
Sub-Mariner #53 
Thor #197 
Thor #198 
Thor #201 
Thor #205 
Warlock #3 

3 in 9.8
Astonishing Tales #9 
Captain America #155 
Fantastic Four #117 
Fantastic Four #120 
Incredible Hulk #151
Iron Man #52 
Marvel Feature #3 
Marvel Team-Up #1 
Sub-Mariner #45 
Sub-Mariner Annual #2 
Thor #206 

Most submissions
Marvel Spotlight #5 - 3789
Hero for Hire #1 – 2946
Tomb of Dracula #1 - 2077
Marvel Premiere #1 - 1916
Defenders #1 - 1503

Fewest submissions
Chili #18 - 2
Chili #19 - 2
Harvey #3 - 2
Harvey #6 - 2
Li'l Kids #4 - 2
Ringo Kid #14 - 2
Chili #20 - 1
Li'l Kids #6 - 1
Millie the Model #199 - 1

Toughest 25¢ books in 9.4+
Special Marvel Edition #4 - 1 in 9.4 (9 in 9.2)
Mighty Marvel Western #16 - 2 in 9.4 (4 in 9.2)
My Love #14 - 3 in 9.4 (7 in 9.2)

Monstrosities
Tomb of Dracula #1 has 54 9.8s, Werewolf by Night #1 has just 3
Chamber of Darkness Annual #1 - 0 in 9.8s (6 in 9.6)
Where Monsters Dwell #12 - 0 in 9.8 (6 in 9.6)
Creatures on the Loose #14 - 0 in 9.8 (6 in 9.6)
Where Monsters Dwell #14 - 0 in 9.8 (1 in 9.6)

Hyborian Tidbits
Conan #11 - only 1 9.8 (37 in 9.6)  
Conan #12 - 4 in 9.8 (19 in 9.6)       

Sgt. Fury can be tough
There are no 9.8 copes of #95, #97, #99, and #105 in the census

The Not OK Corral
Mighty Marvel Western #16 - 2 in 9.4 (4 in 9.2)
Two-Gun Kid #101 - No 9.6+ copies (4 in 9.4)
Western Gunfighter #8 - No 9.6+ copies 4 (1 in 9.4)
Western Kid # 5 - No 9.6+ copies (3 in 9.4)
Wyatt Earp 31 - 1 in 9.6 (5 in 9.4)
Rawhide Kid #100 - No 9.6+ copies (5 in 9.4)
Rawhide Kid #105 - No 9.6+ copies (4 in 9.4)
Ringo Kid #14 - No 9.6+ copies (1 in 9.4)
Ringo Kid #17 - 1 in 9.6 (1 in 9.4)
Outlaw Kid #10 - No 9.6+ copies (7 in 9.4)

 

Barton, I have a Harvey # 6 (and 5) at CGC right now and probably being graded this week. That will bump it from the only 2 submissions list. Ill let you know when its official. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
23 23
Go to topic listing