Grading Contest--with Prize!

[Point Five]

OMG this is exciting!!!

It is! I like the slow unveiling of the scores...I'm not even in the contest and I'm all a-twitter.

[rjpb]

I'm I doing the math correctly? - Nobody picked 8.5 on the Dizzy Dames, right?

[JWKyle]

Come on Subby 4 be nice to me love the roll out are they going in order?

[143ksk]

I'm I doing the math correctly? - Nobody picked 8.5 on the Dizzy Dames, right?

 

That is correct. Only CGC picked 8.5. Of course, Heritage had it at 9.0

[143ksk]

Come on Subby 4 be nice to me love the roll out are they going in order?

 

They are going in order. Unfortunately, numbers 4 -20 will have to wait until January since they're on the cheapo plan.

[thirdgreenham]

congrats on the dizzy dames!

[143ksk]

Book #3

 

 

Sub-Mariner Comics 14 Fall 1944 Timely Comics Universal 5.0 CREAM TO OFF-WHITE

[Scrooge]

I need to stop being so damn conservative with my grading!

[thehumantorch]

I need to stop being so damn conservative with my grading!

 

Ditto, I undergraded most of 'em.

[143ksk]

After books one, two and three

 

11 points

comicdonna

 

9 points

Mio

almoe

universal soldier

sniderwj

rjpb

 

8 points

Sal

mrwoogieman

B3AST

flatrock02

 

7 points

143ksk

Aces

JWK

catrick339

BillS25

 

6 points

comicdey

VK

 

5 points

Theagenes

byosti

toro

 

4 points

14 of Spades

Oakman29

Speedy-D

podboy66

WEBHEAD

Boozad

pinball

 

3 points

Snake Eyes

FUELMAN

thehumantorch

 

2 points

topofthetotem

thirdgreenham

FlyingDonut

 

1 point

Cimm

trmoore54

 

-1 point

timmay

Scrooge

tigers comics

 

-3 points

c-mack

frankbearss

 

[Mio]

After books one and two

 

8 points

Mio

 

6 points

almoe

universal soldier

JWK

comicdonna

 

5 points

Snake Eyes

 

4 points

143ksk

sniderwj

Aces

Theagenes

rjpb

Boozad

byosti

catrick339

 

3 points

Sal

14 of Spades

mrwoogieman

B3AST

Oakman29

Speedy-D

FUELMAN

comicdey

flatrock02

podboy66

 

2 points

BillS25

toro

 

1 point

Cimm

topofthetotem

trmoore54

WEBHEAD

thirdgreenham

FlyingDonut

VK

 

0 points

thehumantorch

 

-1 point

c-mack

timmay

pinball

Scrooge

frankbearss

 

-2 points

tigers comics

 

I foresee my imminent collapse

[rjpb]

I'm I doing the math correctly? - Nobody picked 8.5 on the Dizzy Dames, right?

 

That is correct. Only CGC picked 8.5. Of course, Heritage had it at 9.0

 

It's a nice copy, but 9.0? How is heritage usually on raw HG GA?

 

So CGC is backlogged to January - they taking a winter break or something?

[143ksk]

I'm I doing the math correctly? - Nobody picked 8.5 on the Dizzy Dames, right?

 

That is correct. Only CGC picked 8.5. Of course, Heritage had it at 9.0

 

It's a nice copy, but 9.0? How is heritage usually on raw HG GA?

 

 

They've been hit or miss in the past (most of the Crippen books were significantly overgraded), but seem to have tightened up recently.

[Aces]

After books one, two and three

 

11 points

comicdonna

 

9 points

Mio

almoe

universal soldier

sniderwj

rjpb

 

8 points

Sal

mrwoogieman

B3AST

flatrock02

 

7 points

143ksk

Aces

JWK

catrick339

BillS25

 

6 points

comicdey

VK

 

5 points

Theagenes

byosti

toro

 

4 points

14 of Spades

Oakman29

Speedy-D

podboy66

WEBHEAD

Boozad

pinball

 

3 points

Snake Eyes

FUELMAN

thehumantorch

 

2 points

topofthetotem

thirdgreenham

FlyingDonut

 

1 point

Cimm

trmoore54

 

-1 point

timmay

Scrooge

tigers comics

 

-3 points

c-mack

frankbearss

 

Wow.

Seven points with no bullseyes.

Typical near-miss aces at work...

[VK]

I was spot on with Subby....maybe there's hope for me yet! Congrats on the grades so far!

[Speedy-D]

January???

Sorry, that's not gonna work for me.

[thehumantorch]

I'm I doing the math correctly? - Nobody picked 8.5 on the Dizzy Dames, right?

 

That is correct. Only CGC picked 8.5. Of course, Heritage had it at 9.0

 

It's a nice copy, but 9.0? How is heritage usually on raw HG GA?

 

 

They've been hit or miss in the past (most of the Crippen books were significantly overgraded), but seem to have tightened up recently.

 

The Borock factor???

[asteroid-comix]

 

I had each of the last two books a full 2 points under graded.

 

 

[rjpb]

 

I had each of the last two books a full 2 points under graded.

 

 

Time to start listing raw stuff in the sales thread

[VK]

I gave the Archie a 2.0, which wasn't off too bad, but I only gave the Dames a 6.0.......BUT I did guess it right as being a Church (shouldn't that count for a point bump???)