Top Golden Comic picks

[BucOne-migration]

 

What are your top 5 and why?

 

Action Comics #1 - 1st appearance of Superman

Detective Comics #27 - 1st appearance of Batman

Captain America #1 - 1st appearance of Captain America

All American Comics #16 - 1st appearance of Green Lantern

Marvel Comics #1 - 1st Timely and intro Human Torch and Origin Sub Mariner

 

 

[ciorac]

What are your top 5 and why?

 

Action Comics #1 - 1st appearance of Superman

Detective Comics #27 - 1st appearance of Batman

Captain America #1 - 1st appearance of Captain America

All American Comics #16 - 1st appearance of Green Lantern

Marvel Comics #1 - 1st Timely and intro Human Torch and Origin Sub Mariner

 

 

Trade out Batman #1 for Marvel Comics #1 and it works for me (except I put the Bat #1 at the top of my list)

 

[G.A.tor]

What are your top 5 and why?

 

Action Comics #1 - 1st appearance of Superman

Detective Comics #27 - 1st appearance of Batman

Captain America #1 - 1st appearance of Captain America

All American Comics #16 - 1st appearance of Green Lantern

Marvel Comics #1 - 1st Timely and intro Human Torch and Origin Sub Mariner

 

 

Trade out Batman #1 for Marvel Comics #1 and it works for me (except I put the Bat #1 at the top of my list)

 

[Silver Surfer]

What are your top 5 and why?

 

Action Comics #1 - 1st appearance of Superman

Detective Comics #27 - 1st appearance of Batman

Captain America #1 - 1st appearance of Captain America

All American Comics #16 - 1st appearance of Green Lantern

Marvel Comics #1 - 1st Timely and intro Human Torch and Origin Sub Mariner

 

 

Trade out Batman #1 for Marvel Comics #1 and it works for me (except I put the Bat #1 at the top of my list)

 

 

Hogwash, utter rubbish.

[Forbush-Man]

What are your top 5 and why?

 

Action Comics #1 - 1st appearance of Superman

Detective Comics #27 - 1st appearance of Batman

Captain America #1 - 1st appearance of Captain America

All American Comics #16 - 1st appearance of Green Lantern

Marvel Comics #1 - 1st Timely and intro Human Torch and Origin Sub Mariner

 

 

Trade out Batman #1 for Marvel Comics #1 and it works for me (except I put the Bat #1 at the top of my list)

 

 

Hogwash, utter rubbish.

 

Trade out Detective 27 for Motion Picture Funnies Weekly #1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

That'll get Ciorac & Gator all riled up.

[ciorac]

What are your top 5 and why?

 

Action Comics #1 - 1st appearance of Superman

Detective Comics #27 - 1st appearance of Batman

Captain America #1 - 1st appearance of Captain America

All American Comics #16 - 1st appearance of Green Lantern

Marvel Comics #1 - 1st Timely and intro Human Torch and Origin Sub Mariner

 

 

Trade out Batman #1 for Marvel Comics #1 and it works for me (except I put the Bat #1 at the top of my list)

 

 

Hogwash, utter rubbish.

 

Trade out Detective 27 for Motion Picture Funnies Weekly #1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

That'll get Ciorac & Gator all riled up.

 

I like MPFW #1 much more than Gator does. If I were a Timely collector I would most assuredly want one.

[comicparadox]

No love for Whiz 2? The Big Red Cheese will be very angry.

[thedude]

my personal picks would be:

 

Action #1

Detective #27

Superman #1

Batman #1

Captain America #1

[G.A.tor]

my Wednesday list

superman 14

batman 47

wonder woman 7

sensation 6

cap 46

[Old Fashion PB and J]

Action 1

Tec 27

Batman 1

Captain America 1

All Star Comics 3

[Forbush-Man]

My real picks, in no exact order:

 

Action Comics #1

Detective Comics # 27

Marvel Comics #1

Captain America Comics #1

Motion Picture Funnies Weekly #1

[Primetime]

My Fav Five...

 

Marvel Mystery 9

Tec 27

Tec 29

Tec 31

Cap 1

[Paratrooper]

National Comics #18

Star Spangled War Stories #45

Terrific Comics #4

Fight Comics #19

Foxhole #1

 

[G.A.tor]

Here is my tuesday list

Terrific 5

Detective 31

Human torch 12

Marvel mystery 46

Action 7

[thedude]

Here is my tuesday list

Terrific 5

Detective 31

Human torch 12

Marvel mystery 46

Action 7

 

Action #7

[Silver Surfer]

Marvel Comics #1 (October)

Marvel Comics #1 (November)

Captain America #1

Detective Comics #27

Action Comics #1

 

[Ferdelance]

My Pics for today.

 

Suspense 3

Capt 27

Capt 37

Thrilling 41

Weird Mysteries 5

[ciorac]

Here is my tuesday list

Terrific 5

Detective 31

Human torch 12

Marvel mystery 46

Action 7

 

Nearly as lame as your Wednesday list. Except for the Tec 31 of course.

 

 

 

j/k Gator, Action 7 is awesome too.

[G.A.tor]

Here is my tuesday list

Terrific 5

Detective 31

Human torch 12

Marvel mystery 46

Action 7

 

Nearly as lame as your Wednesday list. Except for the Tec 31 of course.

 

 

 

j/k Gator, Action 7 is awesome too.

well, since you asked, here is my Thursday list:

Batman 1

Action 23

Mystic Comics 10

Daring Mystery Comics 1

Whiz 22

[aardvark88]

Wed. picks:

1. Action #7

2. Suspense comics 3 (Continental)

3. Reform School Girl nn

4. Marvel Mystery b/w "annual"

5. Capt Amer b/w "annual"

6. Double Action # 1